Acquire and refresh permitted sources without losing temporal evidence #15

Closed
opened 2026-10-04 22:20:38 +00:00 by kilo · 7 comments
Member

Parent: #11. Owner: Model Intelligence. G06, G10, G12, G13. Source: shared architecture v1.0 (2026-10-04), supplied section bundle 1–5, 7–10, 12–18; MI brief §4 (time, promotions, data/reuse, operator) and §5. Source/hash availability in #11.

Problem and Evidence

At develop fb7299810fdc4612d4e0559465faef571662c6ef, #9/PR #10 supplies synthetic immutable observations/claims and controlled temporal projection, no source acquisition/normalization/refresh operation. Production users cannot obtain lawful current evidence from that proof alone. This is a known product gap, not evidence of a vulnerability in a nonexistent fetcher.

Result and Scope

After #12 proves value/rights and #13 establishes publication semantics, implement the smallest permitted-source acquisition/normalization and refresh slice with demonstrated model/benchmark/surface/public-price-plan-promotion coverage. Preserve #14 identity/calibration boundary; expand only to accepted source scope. Do not recreate upstream catalogs, build a generic crawler/scheduler, store account state or publish source data without rights.

Acceptance

  1. Reproducible captures/provenance record source and revision/reference, subject, acquisition/observation/publication time when known, applicability and independent freshness, uncertainty and rights. Preserve benchmark context/units, alias/channel/configuration distinctions and public offer price/quota units, plan/model/access/harness scope, dates/timezones/conditions. Missing boundaries remain unknown, not guessed.
  2. Refresh failure/disappearance leaves last successful version/history intact, never renews freshness/promotion or signals cessation. Future revisions, explicit withdrawal, correction, natural expiry, conflicting sources, missing current price and formatting-only changes have distinct tested outcomes using #9 invariants and #13 conformance. Unknown never becomes zero/false or private entitlement.
  3. Inspect reuse parsers/source adapters/temporal algorithms/mappings/fixtures/tests at exact revisions; compare safety and negative semantics as well as code/data/API redistribution rights. Reuse existing refresh mechanisms where sufficient; document why any local code remains necessary and required NOTICE/attribution.
  4. Threat-model untrusted retrieval and parsing, including malicious source text/prompt injection, malformed/oversized content, redirect/unexpected origin and partial responses. Define evidence-based limits/allowances at implementation time, not invented numeric budgets now. Inputs never execute commands/change authority; reject or quarantine unsafe/invalid evidence with diagnostics and no secret leakage.
  5. Interrupted/mixed refresh cannot publish a partial artifact as complete. Test deterministic retries/recovery, source schema changes and conflicts; define source-version/config/data migration and safe rollback without erasing prior evidence. Expose source freshness/failure facts for #16 and document source-specific operator remediation.

Ownership, Dependencies and Priority

MI produces normalized public evidence and source health; Router consumes admitted #13 artifact and decides account/channel applicability/fallback. #12/#13/#14 precede this implementation; professional release acceptance depends on it. Priority P2, gated by proof/contracts because lawful useful source scope is not yet established; recorded now, not discarded as 'later'.
Future source/service/API access, paid terms, credentials if any and owner approval of accepted source scope require separate authorization. Deterministic local fixtures require no product inference. No private telemetry, routing, permissions, service deployment or live task is authorized.

Parent: #11. Owner: Model Intelligence. G06, G10, G12, G13. Source: shared architecture v1.0 (2026-10-04), supplied section bundle 1–5, 7–10, 12–18; MI brief §4 (time, promotions, data/reuse, operator) and §5. Source/hash availability in #11. ## Problem and Evidence At develop `fb7299810fdc4612d4e0559465faef571662c6ef`, #9/PR #10 supplies synthetic immutable observations/claims and controlled temporal projection, no source acquisition/normalization/refresh operation. Production users cannot obtain lawful current evidence from that proof alone. This is a known product gap, not evidence of a vulnerability in a nonexistent fetcher. ## Result and Scope After #12 proves value/rights and #13 establishes publication semantics, implement the smallest permitted-source acquisition/normalization and refresh slice with demonstrated model/benchmark/surface/public-price-plan-promotion coverage. Preserve #14 identity/calibration boundary; expand only to accepted source scope. Do not recreate upstream catalogs, build a generic crawler/scheduler, store account state or publish source data without rights. ## Acceptance 1. Reproducible captures/provenance record source and revision/reference, subject, acquisition/observation/publication time when known, applicability and independent freshness, uncertainty and rights. Preserve benchmark context/units, alias/channel/configuration distinctions and public offer price/quota units, plan/model/access/harness scope, dates/timezones/conditions. Missing boundaries remain unknown, not guessed. 2. Refresh failure/disappearance leaves last successful version/history intact, never renews freshness/promotion or signals cessation. Future revisions, explicit withdrawal, correction, natural expiry, conflicting sources, missing current price and formatting-only changes have distinct tested outcomes using #9 invariants and #13 conformance. Unknown never becomes zero/false or private entitlement. 3. Inspect reuse parsers/source adapters/temporal algorithms/mappings/fixtures/tests at exact revisions; compare safety and negative semantics as well as code/data/API redistribution rights. Reuse existing refresh mechanisms where sufficient; document why any local code remains necessary and required NOTICE/attribution. 4. Threat-model untrusted retrieval and parsing, including malicious source text/prompt injection, malformed/oversized content, redirect/unexpected origin and partial responses. Define evidence-based limits/allowances at implementation time, not invented numeric budgets now. Inputs never execute commands/change authority; reject or quarantine unsafe/invalid evidence with diagnostics and no secret leakage. 5. Interrupted/mixed refresh cannot publish a partial artifact as complete. Test deterministic retries/recovery, source schema changes and conflicts; define source-version/config/data migration and safe rollback without erasing prior evidence. Expose source freshness/failure facts for #16 and document source-specific operator remediation. ## Ownership, Dependencies and Priority MI produces normalized public evidence and source health; Router consumes admitted #13 artifact and decides account/channel applicability/fallback. #12/#13/#14 precede this implementation; professional release acceptance depends on it. Priority P2, gated by proof/contracts because lawful useful source scope is not yet established; recorded now, not discarded as 'later'. Future source/service/API access, paid terms, credentials if any and owner approval of accepted source scope require separate authorization. Deterministic local fixtures require no product inference. No private telemetry, routing, permissions, service deployment or live task is authorized.
Author
Member

Explicit delivery boundary: this task owns the production permitted-source producer, including complete snapshot publication through the mechanism agreed/proved in #13, not only extraction into Python values. Required receipt demonstrates last complete artifact survives interrupted refresh and no partial artifact is admitted, with provenance/rights and migration diagnostics. Preconditions #12 (accepted value/rights), #13 (publication conformance), #14 (identity boundary); #16 consumes source health, #18 distributes/updates installed artifacts, #19 exercises actual consumer path. Router owns consumption under BioMedical-IT/scarcity-router#173; do not implement its fallback/admission here.

Explicit delivery boundary: this task owns the production permitted-source producer, including complete snapshot publication through the mechanism agreed/proved in #13, not only extraction into Python values. Required receipt demonstrates last complete artifact survives interrupted refresh and no partial artifact is admitted, with provenance/rights and migration diagnostics. Preconditions #12 (accepted value/rights), #13 (publication conformance), #14 (identity boundary); #16 consumes source health, #18 distributes/updates installed artifacts, #19 exercises actual consumer path. Router owns consumption under https://forgejo.creatidy.com/BioMedical-IT/scarcity-router/issues/173; do not implement its fallback/admission here.
Author
Member

Final consumer/safety matches: Router BioMedical-IT/scarcity-router#176 (MI adoption) and BioMedical-IT/scarcity-router#184 (private access/cost enforcement). MI owns public source normalization/publication; no account/entitlement logic. Separate runtime workspace isolation belongs to Kernel Creatidy/creatidy-kernel#50 and Router BioMedical-IT/scarcity-router#180. This task's prospective untrusted-fetch/parser safety remains local MI work, not a duplicate sandbox or claim of an existing vulnerability.

Final consumer/safety matches: Router https://forgejo.creatidy.com/BioMedical-IT/scarcity-router/issues/176 (MI adoption) and https://forgejo.creatidy.com/BioMedical-IT/scarcity-router/issues/184 (private access/cost enforcement). MI owns public source normalization/publication; no account/entitlement logic. Separate runtime workspace isolation belongs to Kernel https://forgejo.creatidy.com/Creatidy/creatidy-kernel/issues/50 and Router https://forgejo.creatidy.com/BioMedical-IT/scarcity-router/issues/180. This task's prospective untrusted-fetch/parser safety remains local MI work, not a duplicate sandbox or claim of an existing vulnerability.
Author
Member

Public-source coverage includes public capability and limit evidence (not only boolean support or benchmark scores), such as context/output/interface limits when the accepted sources provide them. Preserve native units, channel/version/configuration scope and missing/unknown/conflicting status through #14 mapping and #13 publication. Test source disagreement and absent/currently unsupported numeric-limit evidence without defaulting unknown to unlimited/zero or manufacturing entitlement. This is normalized public evidence scope, not a private task classifier or invented limit schema.

Public-source coverage includes public capability and limit evidence (not only boolean support or benchmark scores), such as context/output/interface limits when the accepted sources provide them. Preserve native units, channel/version/configuration scope and missing/unknown/conflicting status through #14 mapping and #13 publication. Test source disagreement and absent/currently unsupported numeric-limit evidence without defaulting unknown to unlimited/zero or manufacturing entitlement. This is normalized public evidence scope, not a private task classifier or invented limit schema.
Author
Member

Review correction adds production provenance consumer Creatidy/creatidy-kernel#55 after Router #176 admission. MI #15 supplies lawful complete public evidence; Kernel #55 preserves actually utilized artifact/evidence-cut semantics without inventing freshness or entitlement. Runtime workspace/concurrency remains Kernel #50/#59/#61, not MI parser isolation. All links are registered criteria, not implementation claims.

Review correction adds production provenance consumer https://forgejo.creatidy.com/Creatidy/creatidy-kernel/issues/55 after Router #176 admission. MI #15 supplies lawful complete public evidence; Kernel #55 preserves actually utilized artifact/evidence-cut semantics without inventing freshness or entitlement. Runtime workspace/concurrency remains Kernel #50/#59/#61, not MI parser isolation. All links are registered criteria, not implementation claims.
Author
Member

Explicit owner production contract decision received in the current session on 2026-10-08T15:12:59Z; transcribed here under that instruction. This resolves the previously outstanding #15 production semantic prerequisite in principle without reopening completed #13/#14 or any STOP_REVISE delivery.

Owner accepts narrow public identity/applicability/native-limit representation extending #13 under an explicitly NEW versioned grammar. Preserve provider, requested alias/model, actually evidenced physical identity or unknown, model revision, serving channel, surface/interface version and relevant native configuration. Missing/null reasoning_effort, literal none and unsupported effort remain distinct from opaque variant; no implicit cross-context inheritance.

Each typed native-limit assertion retains exact applicable subject/configuration, native dimension/meaning, exact value or explicit unknown, native unit/measurement basis, attributed assertion strength, observation identity and temporal/source/lineage provenance. Total context, input/output allowance and enforceable execution ceiling are different meanings; no inferred conversion/rounding/unlimited defaults. Reuse #13 observation/publication/immutable-cut/strict validation/history/decision-utilization mechanics; unsupported/incomplete updates cannot replace last valid retained bytes. No parallel limit catalog/service/API, global TTL, authority winner, quality score or second calibration.

MI produces evidence only. Router alone maps compatible, equivalent, adequately sourced/temporally valid and unambiguous/conflict-free values into existing hard properties/calibration/eligibility; otherwise explicit non-mapping without weakening requirements. Public evidence grants no entitlement, local adapter support, private quota, execution identity or ratings. Kernel retains task requirements/actual-use ownership.

Owner directs refresh of exact current Router/Kernel contracts/issues/PRs and #15 acceptance before substantive mutation. Kernel49/51 and Router175/179 must be revalidated, not assumed integrated from the earlier snapshot. Kernel52/Router181 are not automatic MI producer prerequisites; applicable downstream executable receipts remain separate. Implement #15 original accepted scope with narrow permitted real public-source capture/normalization, exact-source compatibility/no installed-adoption claim, synthetic/real and negative source/refusal/history proofs. Assess redistribution rights only for actual proposed copied material, not a generic public price/promotion citation barrier.

No Router/Kernel mutation, private operational intake (#17 remains REJECT), automatic calibration, inference/deployment/product GO is authorized. Current clean canonical develop98b270e; full fresh queue selected #15 by explicit P2/predecessor/time/number, initial sanitized make check PASS115. No prior #15 branch/commit/current PR/review exists in recovered delivery evidence; history/counters for other issues retained. Source/contract eligibility revalidation follows.

Explicit owner production contract decision received in the current session on 2026-10-08T15:12:59Z; transcribed here under that instruction. This resolves the previously outstanding #15 production semantic prerequisite in principle without reopening completed #13/#14 or any STOP_REVISE delivery. Owner accepts narrow public identity/applicability/native-limit representation extending #13 under an explicitly NEW versioned grammar. Preserve provider, requested alias/model, actually evidenced physical identity or unknown, model revision, serving channel, surface/interface version and relevant native configuration. Missing/null reasoning_effort, literal none and unsupported effort remain distinct from opaque variant; no implicit cross-context inheritance. Each typed native-limit assertion retains exact applicable subject/configuration, native dimension/meaning, exact value or explicit unknown, native unit/measurement basis, attributed assertion strength, observation identity and temporal/source/lineage provenance. Total context, input/output allowance and enforceable execution ceiling are different meanings; no inferred conversion/rounding/unlimited defaults. Reuse #13 observation/publication/immutable-cut/strict validation/history/decision-utilization mechanics; unsupported/incomplete updates cannot replace last valid retained bytes. No parallel limit catalog/service/API, global TTL, authority winner, quality score or second calibration. MI produces evidence only. Router alone maps compatible, equivalent, adequately sourced/temporally valid and unambiguous/conflict-free values into existing hard properties/calibration/eligibility; otherwise explicit non-mapping without weakening requirements. Public evidence grants no entitlement, local adapter support, private quota, execution identity or ratings. Kernel retains task requirements/actual-use ownership. Owner directs refresh of exact current Router/Kernel contracts/issues/PRs and #15 acceptance before substantive mutation. Kernel49/51 and Router175/179 must be revalidated, not assumed integrated from the earlier snapshot. Kernel52/Router181 are not automatic MI producer prerequisites; applicable downstream executable receipts remain separate. Implement #15 original accepted scope with narrow permitted real public-source capture/normalization, exact-source compatibility/no installed-adoption claim, synthetic/real and negative source/refusal/history proofs. Assess redistribution rights only for actual proposed copied material, not a generic public price/promotion citation barrier. No Router/Kernel mutation, private operational intake (#17 remains REJECT), automatic calibration, inference/deployment/product GO is authorized. Current clean canonical develop98b270e; full fresh queue selected #15 by explicit P2/predecessor/time/number, initial sanitized make check PASS115. No prior #15 branch/commit/current PR/review exists in recovered delivery evidence; history/counters for other issues retained. Source/contract eligibility revalidation follows.
Author
Member

Accepted minimum production contract15692 delivered as candidate PR #34, base98b270e387571decceb9be7d177d122656de9fa3, HEAD2b470187d10cae6ef03aa54eda2f26200d385189, ordinary issue-15-public-evidence-producer. Same invocation/history, initial #15 review budget0/10; no reopening13/14 or STOP_REVISE.

Explicit /2 typed public identity/native limits reuse #13/R2 mechanisms; /1 preserved/rejects new semantics. Original selected models.dev+Z.ai adapter normalizes all eight exact public sources before atomic retained publication; operator health separate, partial/error/history loss cannot activate. Demonstrated real complete artifact49052bytes/29claims/2uncertain promotions. Native total/input-unknown/output/request-parameter bounds, raw benchmark context, aliases/channels, prices/plan credits/cohort/unknown campaign boundaries preserved; no default-free/unlimited, effort inference, calibration or authority winner.

Full sanitized offline makecheck PASS135/all repository gates; exact pinned guarded PURE Router compatibility/refusal proof PASS24, raw MI/installed/live/production-MI-mapping false. Source/consumer pins and updated49/51/175/179 maturity verified;176/55 and executable52/181 separate. Offline packaging+isolated installed native API and NOTICE smoke PASS; models.dev MIT data notice packaged, official own facts/citations only, no foreign code/fixtures/rawpages redistributed. No private data17receiver, service/scheduler/controller, inference/deploy/GO or foreign mutation.

Fresh independent complete-PR exact-HEAD review follows. This issue stays open/PR unmerged until accepted scope/currentness/validation/merge/completion gates; no approval claim from tests alone.

Accepted minimum production contract15692 delivered as candidate PR #34, base98b270e387571decceb9be7d177d122656de9fa3, HEAD2b470187d10cae6ef03aa54eda2f26200d385189, ordinary issue-15-public-evidence-producer. Same invocation/history, initial #15 review budget0/10; no reopening13/14 or STOP_REVISE. Explicit `/2` typed public identity/native limits reuse #13/R2 mechanisms; `/1` preserved/rejects new semantics. Original selected models.dev+Z.ai adapter normalizes all eight exact public sources before atomic retained publication; operator health separate, partial/error/history loss cannot activate. Demonstrated real complete artifact49052bytes/29claims/2uncertain promotions. Native total/input-unknown/output/request-parameter bounds, raw benchmark context, aliases/channels, prices/plan credits/cohort/unknown campaign boundaries preserved; no default-free/unlimited, effort inference, calibration or authority winner. Full sanitized offline makecheck PASS135/all repository gates; exact pinned guarded PURE Router compatibility/refusal proof PASS24, raw MI/installed/live/production-MI-mapping false. Source/consumer pins and updated49/51/175/179 maturity verified;176/55 and executable52/181 separate. Offline packaging+isolated installed native API and NOTICE smoke PASS; models.dev MIT data notice packaged, official own facts/citations only, no foreign code/fixtures/rawpages redistributed. No private data17receiver, service/scheduler/controller, inference/deploy/GO or foreign mutation. Fresh independent complete-PR exact-HEAD review follows. This issue stays open/PR unmerged until accepted scope/currentness/validation/merge/completion gates; no approval claim from tests alone.
Author
Member

Completed #15 through merged PR #34 under the existing owner-authorized loop and production contract15692.

Reviewed base98b270e387571decceb9be7d177d122656de9fa3; approved HEAD764851ad8142a1434fdfd97f9d031d857632d221. Fresh independent whole-PR ordinal6/10 task ses_ee30f1556ffep4x8ktxcz0hkrw: APPROVE/findings empty, full accepted16-file scope/source claims independently verified. Five earlier findings rounds were reproduced/fixed with original regressions and normal commits; counter/history not reset or rewritten.

Actual supported normal merge6b6893b14169d616c41f82a0292386713da77206, exact parents[reviewedbase,approvedHEAD], treea612503ad09472e48d9eafa1ff45c239eda2fe0c identical to approved tree, approved ancestry verified. Same normal checkout returned clean canonical develop by fast-forward. Integrated sanitized locked offline makecheck PASS147, Ruff43formatted/basedpyright0/whitespace; independent exactpinned guarded pure Router24 cases/build/isolatednativewheel+MITNOTICE pass.

Production receipt: deliberately versioned /2 rich public identity/native-limit assertions retain exact values/units/meaning/basis/strength/temporal provenance/history; /1 remains unchanged. Original selected upstream-backed eight-source adapter demonstrates model/alias/benchmark/native context-inputunknown-output-request limits/surface/publicprices-plancredits-cohort/uncertainpromotion coverage, qualified source relationships and complete validated cut activation, atomic retained snapshots/health facts, explicit migration/unsupported rollback refusal and safe recovery. Equivalent numeric spellings preserve original semantic evidence/times/precision; invalid/partial/mixed/unlinked data never invent lineage/withdrawal/freshness/free/unlimited or authority winner.

Real permitted source roundtrip8inputs/29claims/2uncertain/49152bytes verified (latest public-source verification bdd926a911288b95283bab8d3e2bfe520a195c844f4413f8d5dc1809a3e12d67); malicious/origin/redirect/partial/compression/size/encoding/framing/schema/table/property/operation-link negatives preserve artifacts and content-free named-source diagnostics. MIT models.dev selecteddata notice packaged; official ownfactual annotations/citations only, no rawpages/foreigncode/fixtures/AAindexes/images/weights redistribution. No new runtime dependency or catalog/service/crawler/scheduler.

Substantive code: evidence.py/contract.py native schema extension; acquisition.py bounded transport; producer.py immutablepublication/import; zai.py selectedsource normalization/refresh/health; original tests/verifier, NOTICE, package metadata and source/ownership docs. Source versions, copied-material rights and reuse/safety alternatives are recorded.

Receipt does NOT establish installed Router/Kernel adoption, publisher authentication, local adapter/entitlement/private quota/observed execution, complete task cost, permanent ABI, automatic quality calibration, private17intake, source permission outside selectedscope, live inference/release/deployment/main or product GO. Router alone owns mapping/admission/calibration; Kernel tasks/actualuse remain. Current pinned49/51/175/179 integrated; applicable downstream176/55 and52/181/#19 installed gates separate. #17 current-intake REJECT/reconsideration criteria preserved. After verified closure, full canonical SELECT resumes for remaining issues' own gates.

Completed #15 through merged PR #34 under the existing owner-authorized loop and production contract15692. Reviewed base98b270e387571decceb9be7d177d122656de9fa3; approved HEAD764851ad8142a1434fdfd97f9d031d857632d221. Fresh independent whole-PR ordinal6/10 task ses_ee30f1556ffep4x8ktxcz0hkrw: APPROVE/findings empty, full accepted16-file scope/source claims independently verified. Five earlier findings rounds were reproduced/fixed with original regressions and normal commits; counter/history not reset or rewritten. Actual supported normal merge6b6893b14169d616c41f82a0292386713da77206, exact parents[reviewedbase,approvedHEAD], treea612503ad09472e48d9eafa1ff45c239eda2fe0c identical to approved tree, approved ancestry verified. Same normal checkout returned clean canonical develop by fast-forward. Integrated sanitized locked offline makecheck PASS147, Ruff43formatted/basedpyright0/whitespace; independent exactpinned guarded pure Router24 cases/build/isolatednativewheel+MITNOTICE pass. Production receipt: deliberately versioned `/2` rich public identity/native-limit assertions retain exact values/units/meaning/basis/strength/temporal provenance/history; `/1` remains unchanged. Original selected upstream-backed eight-source adapter demonstrates model/alias/benchmark/native context-inputunknown-output-request limits/surface/publicprices-plancredits-cohort/uncertainpromotion coverage, qualified source relationships and complete validated cut activation, atomic retained snapshots/health facts, explicit migration/unsupported rollback refusal and safe recovery. Equivalent numeric spellings preserve original semantic evidence/times/precision; invalid/partial/mixed/unlinked data never invent lineage/withdrawal/freshness/free/unlimited or authority winner. Real permitted source roundtrip8inputs/29claims/2uncertain/49152bytes verified (latest public-source verification bdd926a911288b95283bab8d3e2bfe520a195c844f4413f8d5dc1809a3e12d67); malicious/origin/redirect/partial/compression/size/encoding/framing/schema/table/property/operation-link negatives preserve artifacts and content-free named-source diagnostics. MIT models.dev selecteddata notice packaged; official ownfactual annotations/citations only, no rawpages/foreigncode/fixtures/AAindexes/images/weights redistribution. No new runtime dependency or catalog/service/crawler/scheduler. Substantive code: evidence.py/contract.py native schema extension; acquisition.py bounded transport; producer.py immutablepublication/import; zai.py selectedsource normalization/refresh/health; original tests/verifier, NOTICE, package metadata and source/ownership docs. Source versions, copied-material rights and reuse/safety alternatives are recorded. Receipt does NOT establish installed Router/Kernel adoption, publisher authentication, local adapter/entitlement/private quota/observed execution, complete task cost, permanent ABI, automatic quality calibration, private17intake, source permission outside selectedscope, live inference/release/deployment/main or product GO. Router alone owns mapping/admission/calibration; Kernel tasks/actualuse remain. Current pinned49/51/175/179 integrated; applicable downstream176/55 and52/181/#19 installed gates separate. #17 current-intake REJECT/reconsideration criteria preserved. After verified closure, full canonical SELECT resumes for remaining issues' own gates.
kilo closed this issue 2026-10-08 19:27:07 +00:00
Sign in to join this conversation.
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference
Creatidy/model-intelligence#15
No description provided.