Align Scarcity Router with the Creatidy system architecture and register actionable gaps #173
Labels
No labels
accessibility
bug
documentation
duplicate
enhancement
good first issue
help wanted
invalid
P1
P2
P3
question
wontfix
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
No due date set.
Dependencies
No dependencies set.
Reference
Creatidy/scarcity-router#173
Loading…
Add table
Add a link
Reference in a new issue
No description provided.
Delete branch "%!s()"
Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?
Goal
Owner-selected documentation/planning alignment of Scarcity Router with Creatidy shared system architecture v1.0 (2026-10-04), covering G01-G13 with Router-owned work distinguished from Creatidy Kernel, Model Intelligence and Console ownership. Deliver one documentation PR to develop and register every known actionable Router gap without implementing it. Include the owner's subsequent current-tree/mutable-surface terminology remediation and full final reviewer report.
Why
The owner explicitly mandates full, coherent products, not loss of known requirements behind a minimal release. Existing #85 and #146 are completed gateway/D-056 architecture deliveries, not this new cross-product alignment. Code proves integrated behavior, not conformance to a superseding goal or live deployment. Current fetched develop is
8d9d4b04bcb23fe19ff702b6209fbcb1537cdf1b(2026-10-04), equal to the source's historical Router revision; open PR #170 is not integrated and overlaps newer merged #172.Source and Interpretation
Creatidy_architektura_systemu_2026-10-04.md, v1.0, supplied SHA-2564e64121599ac30896afb77574b2fd16cddfc3420afde37108611715c24b56e92. Full file not found in workspace searches; use the owner's complete repository-specific brief, sections 1-5, 7-13, 14-18 of the source, without claiming to have verified the file bytes. Preserve Agreed / Verified / Proposed clarification / To prove. Do not invent subsection titles, endpoints, payloads, numeric budgets or cross-product issue numbers.The owner's later 2026-10-04 terminology instruction supersedes the earlier brief's naming explanation: use the distinct canonical Creatidy Kernel / creatidy-kernel and Scarcity Router / scarcity-router names directly. Delete unnecessary erroneous naming text rather than preserving an alias, typo interpretation, renamed product or additional component. Responsibilities are unchanged; no redesign is authorized. Record the supersession in D-068 without institutionalizing the wrong name.
Scope
Acceptance Criteria
Constraints
Documentation and issue registration only; no deployment/services/permissions/secrets/branch protection/release/main changes. No product inference or real task execution. One issue/branch/PR. Threat model unchanged: no new credential or network exposure, no implied workspace authority. Classification: documentation/planning, not implementation of security-critical changes. Budget: 120 minutes from session start, one initial independent review, at most one remediation, one narrow final verification; one concrete-diagnosis retry per worker/reviewer. Frozen review HEAD/base; no pushes during review. No new review controller; later owner clarification does not reset budget.
Reuse
Inspect local selector/routing/pin/admission/inventory/worker/UI first. Rich, OpenTelemetry, selected LiteLLM translators/tests and Langfuse/OpenRouter patterns are candidates only; implementation issues must prove exact revision/files/license/semantics/negative tests/security/maintenance before adoption. MI owns external fact collection; no parallel Router crawler.
Links
Creation and later clarification explicitly select this documentation task; they do not authorize execution of the registered future issues.
Durable Audit Checkpoint
Correction after independent review694: the initial negative Console-consumer conclusion below has been replaced by actual OPEN Console #2, #3 and #12 coverage, already linked in Router #183 comment14299 before this checkpoint. The prior conclusion was inaccurate, not an owner decision; no duplicate task is needed.
Canonical base:
8d9d4b04bcb23fe19ff702b6209fbcb1537cdf1b; branchdocs/173-creatidy-system-alignment. Change is 21 existing English documentation/agent files; no product implementation, public schemas, ratings, secrets, permissions or services changed. D-068 records agreed ownership/evidence direction; U-014 preserves the D-063 native coding/workspace conflict pending owner-reviewed migration.Actual Registered Work
Reused existing #139 TLS, #140 admin UX, #141 composed/live program acceptance and #165 concrete cancellation; no duplicate or silent closure. G01/G02/G03/G11 remain Kernel #47/#53, #49, #54, #59/#61 responsibilities. All new functional tasks remain OPEN, not integration receipts.
Kernel alignment #46 and MI alignment #11 counterpart criteria were read and linked; later review corrected the missed Console evidence already present on our issue. No other repository was mutated. Registration/green tests are not READY_FOR_LIVE_TASK.
Historical Validation and Review Scope
The first
uv sync --only-devandmake checkpassed: 2674 tests OK/15 runtime probes skipped,619.426s; basedpyright0/0/0; diff whitespace clean. Subsequent exact-SHA gates and review outcomes belong in the delivery comments/PR. No inference/live task/deployment/service change; synthetic localhost harnesses only.Original120minbudget from22:11Z: one fresh independent whole-PR/backlog review, at most one remediation and narrow final verification; no pushes during review. Documentation/planning classification; future security-critical implementation separately gated. Branch-protection read denied due admin permission; no requirements guessed or changed. This correction does not reset budget or pretend the initial review passed.
Frozen Delivery and Terminology Clarification
Documentation PR: BioMedical-IT/scarcity-router#187 (OPEN, unmerged).
Base:
8d9d4b04bcb23fe19ff702b6209fbcb1537cdf1b; HEAD:a57ed0c4e6154230961480acbadabcffacb8bd4a. Single issue-scoped documentation commit, 21 existing files, no merge commits or product implementation/schema/rating changes.The owner's later naming instruction superseded the earlier explanation. Removed the unnecessary naming sentence in architecture and this mutable issue body; D-068 records real Creatidy Kernel and Scarcity Router names directly, not an alias, renamed product or new component. Classification for both corrected occurrences: removed as unnecessary; no Kernel-versus-Router guess. Complete committed exact and case/formatting git sweeps: zero matches, including hidden tracked workflows/context. All 21 open issue titles/descriptions and 19 current comments across 15 threads were inspected; #173 was the only matching mutable body and was subsequently reread clean. PR #170 description is clean, comments metadata0. No closed historical record or Git history rewritten; no historical quotation needed retention in inspected scope. This update and PR text do not reintroduce the removed term.
Final full
make checkafter owner clarification: 2674 tests OK, 15 runtime probes skipped, 597.455s, built-in basedpyright0/0/0. Separate final basedpyright0/0/0, focused interface guardrails42OK, package artifact/isolated install checks allPASS, whitespace clean. No inference/live task or service/secret/permission changes.Fresh independent reviewer dispatched through the native Task tool as distinct session
ses_ef6b19e21ffeeMnBHQSLA5J1Ef, reviewing complete frozen PR + registered backlog, UX/terminology/evidence/ownership. No named model override requested; the tool supplies distinct session dispatch, not resolved model/runtime identity metadata, so model identity is RUNTIME_UNOBSERVABLE unless independent machine evidence becomes available. No pushes during review. One initial review, optional one remediation/narrow final verification; total original budget remains120min. Full final reviewer report will distinguish substantive exact-SHA verdict, formal Forgejo state, CI availability and open functional gaps.kilo referenced this issue2026-10-12 22:57:07 +00:00