G04: Prove the executable recommendation, admission and exact-pin contract with Kernel #174
Labels
No labels
accessibility
bug
documentation
duplicate
enhancement
good first issue
help wanted
invalid
P1
P2
P3
question
wontfix
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
No due date set.
Blocks
Depends on
#177 G07: Define explicit local outcome export consumption and cautious task-level cost calibration
Creatidy/scarcity-router
#175 G05: Map rich Kernel task and harness requirements into monotone Router eligibility
Creatidy/scarcity-router
#178 G04: Fix exact model-variant narrowing in route_request without changing gateway pin admission
Creatidy/scarcity-router
Reference
Creatidy/scarcity-router#174
Loading…
Add table
Add a link
Reference in a new issue
No description provided.
Delete branch "%!s()"
Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?
Goal
Product owner: Scarcity Router; G04, with G01/G03 consumer dependencies. Source: Creatidy shared architecture v1.0 (2026-10-04), sections 1-5, 7-13, 14-18 as supplied in parent #173. Produce a public, tested executable-selection/admission/pin contract that Kernel/harness consumers can use without reconstructing a target or adding a second inventory/ranker.
Why and Current Evidence
At Router develop
8d9d4b04bcb23fe19ff702b6209fbcb1537cdf1b,machine_api.py/selection_app.select_from_inputsreturnSelectionDecision, including explicit effort, but no resource binding. Authenticated control/v1/selectcalls that same recommendation seam.routing_core.RouteDecision,PinnedTarget,route_requestandadmit_pinned_targetexist; gatewaysr-pin:<resource_id>/<provider>/<model>/<variant>is documented in execution-surface. #87/#88 delivered these primitives, not their Kernel consumption. Kernel #11 andadapters/scarcity_router.pyconsume recommendation-only model/effort with controller binding, not gateway execution. Fact: public recommendation and executable admission are distinct contracts. Hypothesis to prove: the existing composed surface can expose the missing selection result without a new independently started service/API.Scope and Non-Goals
First map existing public/library/control/client seams and actual harness preservation. Freeze the smallest contract and compatibility/migration decision before code. Router owns inventory, route/admission/pin producer; Kernel owns consumption and immutable Attempt binding. Then implement Router-side missing exposure only if proved necessary and producer-consumer fixtures against version-pinned Kernel/harness behavior. No per-request allowed_models invented by analogy, no new global protocol/ontology, no Kernel scheduler/intake/review code, no autonomous rerouting.
Acceptance Criteria
Dependencies and Order
Refs #173; known Kernel consumer foundation Creatidy/creatidy-kernel#11. New Kernel G04 counterpart not found at registration; link it when registered, do not create it here. Agree rich requirement mapping (G05) and identity/protocol guarantees (G10), prove producer output, then Kernel Attempt/harness binding, then separately authorized live acceptance. These prerequisites do not block documenting today's public contract.
Constraints, Reuse and Priority
First-priority integration prerequisite: a model recommendation is insufficient to guarantee the actually executable route. Reuse local routing/pin/admission/coordinator, frozen parsers and Kernel allocator conformance. Compare alternatives ADOPT -> VENDOR/COPY -> PORT -> ADAPT -> BUILD; external translators only after exact revision/files/license/attribution/negative semantics/security/dependency/maintenance proof. No credentials or prompts in fixtures/logs; no consumer reads Router DB or bypasses auth. Future acceptance may require running Router/Kernel/harness and explicit inference/effect authority; this registration grants none. Human review/merge and full repo gates required.
Cross-product closeout reread: the registration-time missing consumer is now Creatidy/creatidy-kernel#52 (durable Attempt-bound route/pin consumption), after Creatidy/creatidy-kernel#47 (separate harness-control/backend-compatibility proof) and #51 (approved requirements). Router owns this producer contract and #178/#179 defects; Kernel owns consumption, not duplicate inventory/ranking. Affected workspace-editing lanes additionally require accepted Router #180 authority/migration before enablement. Producer proof -> consumer binding -> separately authorized installed acceptance (Kernel #60 / Router #141). All counterpart issues are OPEN, not delivery receipts.
Owner decision 2026-10-05T16:41:45Z in SAME /loop invocation 2026-10-05T12:38:32Z: #179 acceptance now permits deterministic Router identity/effort correction and closure after normal validation/independent review. REAL_HARNESS_IDENTITY_ACCEPTANCE remains a separate OPEN integration gate under #174/#181: version-pinned, separately authorized real-harness receipt distinguishing requested/resolved/dispatched/observed facts. Dispatch/configuration/synthetic fixtures never attest physical execution; #180 still governs affected workspace-editing lanes. No live inference, effects or broader readiness authority added.
New owner-authorized /loop selects this explicit FIRST-priority producer task after maintenance #202/PR203 verified integrated at
edd31326d4. Reassessed prerequisites175/178/179 are actually integrated; Kernel51 current source73e3af45c911aa9ae8c26b97bf0ec9f452063f10 preserves non-reference approved requirement recommendation, not executable consumption. Kernel52 and REAL_HARNESS_IDENTITY_ACCEPTANCE are later integration/acceptance, not producer-start prerequisites.Contract-first D077 frozen in the feature checkout before code: additive /v1/route on existing gateway/inference bearer/core, complete TaskRequirement/RequestBinding, actual decision plus ready existing sr-pin spelling/catalog effort/separately versioned retained context. Explicit execution_requirements member rechecks current profiles/version+expansion/grants/quality/registry/controls before exact admission; no ranking/substitution, trustedmetadata, cache/receipt authority, new service or invented allowlist. Narrow inert producer-response helper validates retained expected request and prepares outgoing pin/context automatically. Ordinary clients/frozen recommendation interfaces stay unchanged. If a harness strips BOTH context+pin a stateless server cannot infer the lost Attempt; that harness remains unsupported/unaccepted, not relabelled as a new Attempt. Current Kernel52/realharness receipt is not fabricated.
Small scoped producer implementation/offline conformance in progress, security_critical exact approval plus mandatory direct-Codex Daybreak gate retained. No live inference/billing/workspace tools, deployments or cross-repository mutation authorized/performed. Engineering/recovery120min, maximum10 counted whole-PR reviews with persistent ordinals; independent complete review will assess all acceptance stages before integration/closure.
Terminal STOP_REVISE for this new owner-authorized /loop delivery, not WAIT/QUEUE_EMPTY. PR204 preserved open/unmerged at HEAD8409d5da6665f04c531a0d4f7879b74184f51168, baseedd31326d4abe5cc282adb419cb54c78d4677ec4. Eight ordinary scoped owner commits, clean checkout. Latest full sanitized gate2823tests/17skips/type0/exit0, locked sync/explicittypes/whitespace PASS. Native whole-PR ordinal8 APPROVE findings[] and164 independent safe tests; mandatory direct-Codex requested gpt-daybreak-blue-latest ordinal9 REQUEST_CHANGES at same exact objects.
Unresolved verified defects: P1 routing_core TARGET_EXCLUSION_REASON_CODES omits adapter_unavailable although availability emits it; actual synthetic select/helper/adapter retirement/exact admission reproduces RouteContractValidationError(no typed code), ZERO dispatch. P2 authoritative Requests allowlist execution-surface.md587-598 omits execution_requirements, contradicting new supported context. Raw restricted review retained; no credentials inspected/copied and no installed/live/physical/billing receipt claimed.
Nine of ten whole-PR invocations consumed. Any fix changes HEAD and requires TWO fresh independent whole-PR gates: ordinary approval plus separate additional direct-Codex Daybreak. Only one slot remains; no admissible repair can close both without review11 or weakening/combining gates. Therefore no further patch, merge, closure or counter reset; no extra review merely to fill counter. History1COMMENT,2-7REQUEST_CHANGES,8APPROVE,9securityREQUEST_CHANGES retained in excluded ledger.
Maintenance202/PR203 was actually integrated/accepted/closed, and SAME primary invocation continued normal fresh SELECT into this FIRST-priority task automatically. Final develop remainsedd3132. Fresh complete Router queue still has executable/foundational work; MI15 producer exists,185 open status is not an inactivity blocker, MI19 stays downstream acceptance. Started delivery/review stop prevents skipping to another issue. Original Kernel52/REAL_HARNESS_IDENTITY_ACCEPTANCE remain separate open integration/acceptance, never fabricated or waived.
Explicit owner decision 2026-10-10T08:33:10Z reauthorizes continuation of the SAME preserved /loop invocation and this existing delivery. ONE-TIME issue174/PR204 review ceiling increases from10 to12 only. Preserve ordinals1-9 including ordinary8APPROVE and direct-Codex Daybreak9REQUEST_CHANGES; next10, absolute ceiling12, never13/reset/renumber. Global default10 remains unchanged.
Revalidated canonical issueopen/unexcluded, PR204open/unmerged targetdevelop, preserved cleancheckout HEAD8409d5da6665f04c531a0d4f7879b74184f51168/baseedd31326d4abe5cc282adb419cb54c78d4677ec4 and durable ledger/history. Accepted remediation: fix availability/global admission vocabulary mismatch including adapter_unavailable and analogous worker_continuation_unavailable with typed503/no-dispatch exact-binding regressions; align authoritative request allowlist with actual execution_requirements parser, no unnecessary wire change. Required full validation/fresh ordinarywholePR then separate direct official Codex gpt-daybreak-blue-latest exact approvals/currentness/merge/integratedacceptance/conditionalclosure. Immediately continue normal freshSELECT in sameprimary afterward, no newownerprompt. Existing security/acceptance/technical recovery and no crossrepo/main/release/deploy/liveinference boundaries remain; no acceptancewaiver.
Owner exception delivery reaches terminal STOP_REVISE at absolute12/12; same invocation/history preserved. Original9P1availability vocabulary and9P2Requestsallowlist findings FIXED in samePR204commit07667d8e269529039ede003d52a1f5a635663cd3. Analogous worker_continuation_unavailable covered; global vocabulary+sorted admission codes and explicit503/samepin/ZEROdispatch regressions PASS, document/parser keyset parity PASS. Full locked sanitized2826tests17skips/type0/exit0; sync/explicittypes/whitespace PASS.
Ordinal10fresh ordinarywholePR APPROVE/findings[] exact07667d8/baseedd31326d4abe5cc282adb419cb54c78d4677ec4. Ordinal11direct official Codex0.159.3 requestedgpt-daybreak-blue-latest REQUEST_CHANGES, NEWP2: public response unroutable_identities retains fullcatalog model/provider/variants outside effectiveclient-visible resources. Complete synthetic denied-provider projection confirms identities visible; catalogpublicknowledge classification required sourceadjudication, parent did not override restricted verdict.
Ordinal12fresh same-model unchangedHEAD whole-review with expanded immutable publiccatalog/product/architecture/machine-interface authority FAILED beforeturn/start: CLIinput1,305,129characters exceeds1,048,576, exit1/no verdict. Infrastructure error is not a fabricated code finding. Failed dispatch consumes finalordinal; sourcebundle reduction is diagnosed but anotherfreshreview requires forbidden13. No counterreset/renumber, default10forotherissuesunchanged; no codepatchwithoutbothfreshgates capacity.
No exactsecurityAPPROVE, so no merge/closure or skippedstarted174delivery. PR204 remains open clean07667d8, developedd3132. ECONNRESET recovered existing completed results, no duplicatevalidation/review11. FreshfullRouterqueue14/page2empty, sixexactwontfix exclusions; nonexcludedwork remains. MIproducer938f416 exists;185owneligibility not blockedmerelybyopenstate,176requires185+approvedRouteradmission,MI19downstreamacceptance. Not WAIT/QUEUE_EMPTY/inactivity. No installed/live/physical/billingreceipt/main/release/deploy/otherrepo mutation.
Explicit owner decision2026-10-10T18:31:23Z resumes SAME preserved /loop2026-10-09T23:49:05Z and selected174/PR204, issue-local ceiling12->16 ONLY. Preserve consumed1-12 including failedoversized12; next13ordinary,14required directofficialCodexgpt-daybreak-blue-latest afterordinarypass,15-16 only if BOTH freshgates remainpossible. Absolute16/no17, no global10policychange/counterreset/replacementPR/historyrewrite/securitybypass.
Revalidated canonicalissueopen/unexcluded, PR204open/unmerged/develop, cleanlocal+remoteHEAD07667d8e269529039ede003d52a1f5a635663cd3 andcurrentbase/merge-baseedd31326d4abe5cc282adb419cb54c78d4677ec4. Owner classifies unroutable identity projection findingACTIONABLE: fixsmallpublicprojection usingexistingeffectiveauth/samecoherentstate; preserve internaldecision/ranking/schema/types/exactbinding/auditprovenance, scrub equivalentwhole-response fields when demonstrated. Focuseddeniedprovider/resource/mixed/variants/empty/change regressions, fullvalidationdurableproof; no knownactionabledefectatreview.
Reviewerpreparation is engineering, no model dispatch/ordinal consumption: freshcompletefrozenreadonlycheckout, directsource/test/contractinspection, concisechecked-size prompt, no massiveinline/history/priorfindings/conclusions/desiredverdict, actualofficialCLI availability. Both exactfreshapprovals/currentness/integratedcompleteacceptance before existingPRmerge/conditionalclosure, then SAMEprimary freshSELECT/automaticdeliveries withoutanothermessage. Nootherrepo/main/release/deploy/liveinference. Newprivacyjudgmentwasownerresolved, not re-adjudicated.
Continuation ends BLOCKED on existing PR#204, not merged or approved. Pushed scoped remediation through HEAD
4ade22b66abf426bf62f115f9780d3940d2e60ca; baseedd31326d4abe5cc282adb419cb54c78d4677ec4. Fixes include complete authorized identity/expired-rule projection, canonical combined availability refusals and exact per-resource current adapter bindings. Internal decisions/ranking/audit and ordinary clients remain intact; composed detached-endpoint regression retains the fresh observation, selects the bound sibling and refuses the old pin with typed503/zero dispatch.Final sanitized full gate PASS:2,836tests/17skips/type0/durableexit0;189focused, locked sync, explicit managed basedpyright and whitespace passed. All source is committed/pushed and clean; regression negatives were reproduced against the preceding untouched source.
Owner ceiling16 and all consumed ordinals1-15 are preserved. Review15 returned COMMENT/findings[]: it inspected full source and passed checks, but accessing mixed canonical comment history exposed prior review findings and invalidated its independence. It is not APPROVE. The only valid recovery is a NEW isolated ordinary whole-PR context with acceptance-only canonical inputs, then a DISTINCT officialCodex gpt-daybreak-blue-latest security context. Two invocations are required; only one slot remains. No authorized technical path can fit both without changing the bound or combining/waiving gates. No16dispatch, no17, no counter reset/discount or unreviewable patch. Secure direct-Codex source/read/credential/tool-network isolation and concise prompt were verified before dispatch; security review was never executed, not declared unavailable.
Full fresh queue/dependency check:14openissues,6exactwontfix exclusions,8nonexcluded. Local175/178/179prerequisites are integrated; actual accepted MI publication exists, and185 remains a distinct actionable foundation rather than a missing-MI gate. Kernel52/real-harness acceptance remain separate downstream obligations. This is a started-delivery review-machinery/capacity blocker, not QUEUE_EMPTY, producer absence or an invented owner question. Preserve this PR/branch and both missing approval gates; no merge, closure, main, release, deployment or live inference.
Owner authorization record, source: Adrian's explicit workspace-session message
2026-10-10T21:19:34Z, titled “Scarcity Router — Final #174 Recovery, Observable Codex Reviews, and Automatic /loop Continuation”. This record preserves the complete budget decision and applicable review/integration conditions verbatim, separate from implementation discussion or reviewer findings. Same primary invocation2026-10-09T23:49:05Z; actual current source verified independently at HEAD4ade22b66abf426bf62f115f9780d3940d2e60ca, baseedd31326d4abe5cc282adb419cb54c78d4677ec4. No implementation changes are authorized without newly demonstrated actionable findings.1. Owner decision — final #174 review budget
I authorize a final, conditional review-budget exception for issue #174 / PR #204.
Maximum: 18 whole-PR review invocations.
Preserve all 15 previously consumed ordinals. Review #15 remains a counted
COMMENT. Review #16 has not been consumed.This exception applies exclusively to #174. The default review policy for other issues remains unchanged.
The exception is conditional on successful reviewer-environment preparation before the next dispatch.
No review #19, no counter reset, no replacement PR, no fabricated approval and no security-gate bypass.
5. Complete PR #204
Only after the independence and process-input preflight succeeds, continue review.
Expected sequence:
gpt-daybreak-blue-latestsecurity review, after ordinary approval on the same exact HEAD/base.Both required approvals must cover the exact final objects.
The ordinary reviewer runs in a genuinely fresh isolated context. The Daybreak reviewer runs through the authorized direct Codex path, with no historical findings or requested verdict.
A changed HEAD/base invalidates earlier approvals.
If a review identifies an actionable defect, remediate only when enough review capacity remains to obtain every required fresh approval.
If review #17 identifies a new defect requiring a code change, one remaining ordinal is insufficient for both mandatory reapprovals. Preserve delivery and stop rather than requesting another exception automatically.
Do not combine ordinary and security approvals into a single review.
Do not alter PR #204's workflow rules merely to make its own reviews pass.
6. Merge and close #174
After complete validation and both exact-object approvals:
developthrough authorized Forgejo operations.develop.No
mainpromotion, release, deployment, live inference or cross-repository mutation.9. Hard stop conditions
Preserve all existing review, security and owner-authority boundaries.
For #174, review 18 is the absolute ceiling.
If the remaining budget cannot satisfy both independent approvals, preserve PR #204 and its evidence, return
STOP_REVISE, and report the exact missing gate.Do not silently switch reviewers, waive security checks, reset counters or create a replacement PR to evade the bound.
If a genuinely new owner-controlled decision is required, return
STOP_AND_ASKwith exact evidence and materially distinct alternatives.If authorized technical recovery is exhausted, report
BLOCKEDwith the failed operation and recovery evidence.Only report
QUEUE_EMPTYafter a complete fresh repository-scoped eligibility check.The same message separately authorizes immediate safe external-review observability, a deduplicated separate workflow-maintenance delivery after #174 integration, and automatic continuation of this existing /loop after both deliveries, without an intervening owner prompt. Those operational mandates do not change #174's product acceptance criteria, review independence, mandatory security gate, default budget for other issues or cross-repository/main/release/deployment/live-inference boundaries. Historical implementation discussion and reviewer findings remain in their existing records and are not included here.
Final owner-ceiling18 continuation ends STOP_REVISE: mandatory exact-object direct-Codex security APPROVE is absent, with all18ordinals consumed. No19, source patch, replacement reviewer/PR, counter reset, merge or issue closure.
Source unchanged/clean: HEAD
4ade22b66abf426bf62f115f9780d3940d2e60ca; base/merge-base/currentdevelopedd31326d4abe5cc282adb419cb54c78d4677ec4. Full validation remains source-current:2,836passed/17skips/type0/durableexit0; focused189passed. Ordinary17 nativeses_ed82f9132ffekbDW3aqxXTxPmAAPPROVE/findings[] at exactobjects; actual fresh-context/object/single-command trace audit PASS130calls. No historical findings entered that context.Review18 ACTUALLY ran officialCodex CLI0.159.3 on hostROG, requested
gpt-daybreak-blue-latest; actualbackend model identity UNVERIFIED. Resolvedbinary/home/adrian/.codex/packages/standalone/releases/0.159.3-x86_64-unknown-linux-musl/bin/codex, executable/hash/inode observed; actualPID3570932, wrapper3570929, directchild3570930, Kilo trackedbgp_127dbd583001D5t6fK8797Cfuz. Session01a127db-d66a-7c31-8b86-80322d1ae285; start2026-10-10T22:08:00.978802Z, end22:08:16.033137Z. CLIexit0 is durably verified but is NOT approval: retrievedlastmessage failed validity/safety checking; original verdict was not retained and cannot be reconstructed. Kilo wrapperexit2 and receiptresult_validation_error=invalid_or_unsafe_result,verdict_validated=false, approvalgatefalse.Safe bounded recovery inspectedreceipt/exit/filteredevents/trackedprocess, confirmedno remainingprocess or uncertainreplay; scratch empty after rejectedrawmessage safety removal. OfficialREADONLYinitialize+thread/read exactsession returned-32600, no recoveredresult and no turn/start/inference/reviewretry. No claim that requiredmodel is unavailable; model/list preflight advertised it. No modelselfreport, sourceapproval, exit0, startup/session label or structuralfailure substitutessecurityapproval. The exact rejection subtype/original verdict remains UNKNOWN; operator retention gap is disclosed, not disguised as sourceREQUEST_CHANGES.
Locally auditable originalreceipt
/tmp/kilo/sr174-observable-reentry/review18/receipt.json; independentexit.json, filteredevents.jsonl, recovery.json. Durable privateGit-excluded archive.review-evidence-180/issue174-observable-20261010/contains those exactsafe artifacts, ordinary17.json/routeaudit, prior9/11/12executionmetadata, accesspreflight and thread-recovery evidence;0700directories/0600files, noauth/privateprompts/rawtranscripts copied. ActualSTARTED/PID/host/version/revision/session/receipt record was visible inKilo, followedbyrunning/exited/retrieved/failedvalidation; foregroundpidfdwait keptprimaryturn active, no daemon/pollingservice orduplicate review.History preserved:1COMMENT;2–7REQUEST_CHANGES;8APPROVE;9REQUEST_CHANGES;10APPROVE;11REQUEST_CHANGES;12FAILEDoversizedpre-start;13–14REQUEST_CHANGES;15COMMENTcontextcontamination;16COMMENTshellallowlist;17APPROVEcurrent;18FAILEDresultvalidation/securityverdictUNVERIFIED. Defaultother-issuebudget unchanged.
Mandatoryfullfreshqueue/dependency check complete:14open/6exactwontfix exclusions/8nonexcluded, notQUEUE_EMPTY. MIaccepted
938f4160493359f9795c3bda081b065afac96b16publication exists; Kernelacceptedfa157fb3890f29cc36e48677c45a588d3b29b4d0consumerbytes stillrecommendation-only. #185/#176 remain distinct actualcontract/admission work, not fictionalmissingMI gates. Kernel52/#181installed/real-harness/physicalacceptance remain downstream explicitowner/harness obligations. Unrelatedqueue eligibility cannotabandonstarted174.Conditionalpost174integration workflow-maintenance registration/PR/merge andsubsequent /loop deliveries didNOTstart becausehardstop precedes integration. Ephemeralpreflight/operatorhelpers are not a permanent reviewedworkflowdelivery. No main/release/deploy/live-inference orcross-repository mutations. This same primaryinvocation preservesPR204 andevidence at the explicitterminal review bound; no automatic furtherexception request.
kilo referenced this issue2026-10-10 22:49:50 +00:00
Owner authorization record. Source: Adrian's explicit workspace-session message
2026-10-10T22:40:14Z, titled “Recover the Codex review-result pipeline before any further security review”. The complete conditional review decision below is preserved verbatim; this is an authority record, not implementation discussion or a previous security verdict. All18 previously consumed ordinals and existing STOP_REVISE remain preserved until the stated preparation conditions pass. PR204 source/head/base must remain unchanged.3. Conditional owner authorization — one review only
If and only if the recovery tests pass, PR #204 remains unchanged, canonical approval #17 is still valid for the exact current HEAD/base, and no genuine safety-policy conflict remains:
I authorize one final security-review invocation, ordinal 19, through direct Codex CLI requesting
gpt-daybreak-blue-latest.The previous maximum of 18 is amended to 19 exclusively under these conditions.
No ordinary review repetition is required if #17 remains valid and the reviewed objects are unchanged.
Obtain and validate a complete independent security verdict. Preserve actual execution receipts.
No review #20, no counter reset and no substitute model.
If Daybreak approves, merge PR #204 after full currentness and acceptance verification, then close #174.
If the preconditions fail or review #19 does not produce valid approval, preserve #174 as STOP_REVISE, open and unmerged. Do not retry automatically.
The same owner message independently authorizes one deduplicated, separate workflow-maintenance delivery regardless of #174's outcome, and expressly authorizes parking exhausted #174 without closing/resetting/replacing it or waiving security. After safe maintenance integration, continue the same /loop using a fresh full canonical queue and reassess185/176 against actual delivered MI contracts. No cross-repository mutation, deployment, release or main promotion. This authority changes neither product acceptance criteria nor review independence, safety rejection or mandatory restricted-model gate; earlier source review opinions/findings are not included.
Owner-authorized bounded recovery checkpoint: review19 remains UNRESERVED/UNEXECUTED because full-source inspection preconditions did not pass. Preserve STOP_REVISE, all18 consumed ordinals, unchanged HEAD4ade22b66abf426bf62f115f9780d3940d2e60ca/baseedd31326d4abe5cc282adb419cb54c78d4677ec4, and exact ordinary17approval. No inferred/lost verdict, source change, safety relaxation, substitute model, replacement PR, review20 or merge/closure.
Historical18 exact failure subtype/verdict is unrecoverable: retained artifacts establish successful CLI/turn completion and an artifact capture/validation rejection, but raw rejected text was removed and subtype collapsed. Controlled tests reproduce16 old rejection paths. Native --output-schema forwards strict generation schema but does not locally validate; native file-write failure/non-JSON can coexist with exit0. Repaired private capture separates stage/reason/exit/turn/JSON/schema/revision/safety/verdict/parent acceptance, preserves bounded diagnostics before raw cleanup and recovers final JSONL without a model call.58offline tests and7 actual-installed-Codex synthetic integration cases passed, explicitly not live-model or complete-review proof.
The remaining native Git/tool-isolation case failed in nested UID0/capdropALL; a third changed attempt matched actual host UID1000 and still did not reach completed source inspection. Default requested-model metadata emitted no tool declarations; a synthetic catalog fixture exposed tools, but this is not real Daybreak capability evidence and was not adopted for live execution. No model19 call was made. Private reports: /tmp/kilo/sr174-native-contract/e2e-summary.json, /tmp/kilo/sr174-result-recovery/validation.json and later controlled test evidence; original18 receipts preserved unchanged.
Per explicit owner message2026-10-10T22:40:14Z and authority record16101, #174 is PARKED FOR THIS INVOCATION, open/unmerged, without counter reset or waived security. This is not invalid/wontfix/duplicate, not QUEUE_EMPTY and not a permanent scope or eligibility change. Its exhausted/conditional security gate remains open. Owner separately authorized maintenance regardless of this outcome: deduplicated issue205 is registered security_critical and will receive its own branch/PR/default10review ledger/full gates; after safe maintenance integration, fresh canonical selection may proceed to unrelated eligible work. No cross-repository/main/release/deployment/live-inference authority.
kilo referenced this issue2026-10-11 00:12:29 +00:00
kilo referenced this issue2026-10-12 22:57:07 +00:00
Direct owner review-cap amendment for #174 / PR #204
This is a Kilo-authored canonical transcription, not an owner-authored Forgejo comment. Direct source: Adrian's native answer
Authorize all threein the active primary Kilo sessionses_ea0104bd7ffe24sCWNMxA400MA, recorded on 2026-10-22. Exact selected answer bytes (UTF-8, no newline) SHA-256:5a1528341a40b7e46f953769c8eac02dc03d465956978a66ce9bd202efc90ebe. The answer selects the #174 option in the immediately preceding owner question, which explicitly scoped this finite allocation.Authorized maximum: 20 whole-PR invocations for Issue #174 / PR #204 only. Preserve all #1-18 outcomes. Supersede the unspent conditional #19 role allocation: #19 is a fresh ordinary whole-PR review on the reconciled exact refs; #20 is the separate owner-manual Daybreak security review only after a valid #19 APPROVE on the same exact refs. No #21, no reset, no transfer, no automatic Daybreak, and no merge/closure before all gates pass. This supersedes only the previous #174 cap/conditional role sequence.
Review #19 reservation
Reserve ordinal #19 as the next fresh ordinary whole-PR review for PR #204 under the direct owner cap amendment in this issue's comment #18355. This is a reservation only; it is not a dispatch, verdict, or approval. Preserve ordinals #1-18.
Frozen objects at reservation: HEAD
a0e5a99afead71bfb5a4adf8fdd1a0c5429bf531; current basecd8fb16b62472b0c4a437a33718c84bbeaaa0ea8; merge-basecd8fb16b62472b0c4a437a33718c84bbeaaa0ea8. PR #204 is open and Forgejo currently reports it mergeable. The exact current PR diff is 15 files; review the full diff and #174 acceptance, D-078, exact-retained-requirements and public-contract boundaries, including the documented separation from installed Kernel/harness acceptance. Do not treat the merge conflict resolution or offline tests as approval of those separate gates.Run only a fresh, separately accountable, read-only visible Kilo ordinary review through the owner-authorized Agent Manager flow. Preserve the current #19 allocation: a valid exact-ref APPROVE is required before the separate owner-manual Daybreak #20; no #21 and no automatic Daybreak. Any HEAD/base change invalidates this reservation.
Corrected reservation for ordinary review #19
The earlier #19 reservation at comment #18374 targeted HEAD
bfea992d5bc4b51c3dae4d990c8d82c07b3515ab. That review was never dispatched. After a documentation-order-only follow-up, the final exact HEAD isa0e5a99afead71bfb5a4adf8fdd1a0c5429bf531; therefore the old reservation is invalidated and #19 remains unconsumed.Reserve the same ordinal #19 for a fresh ordinary whole-PR review of the exact final tree: HEAD
a0e5a99afead71bfb5a4adf8fdd1a0c5429bf531, basecd8fb16b62472b0c4a437a33718c84bbeaaa0ea8, merge-basecd8fb16b62472b0c4a437a33718c84bbeaaa0ea8. The direct owner max-20 authority remains comment #18355; preserve #1-18. #20 remains owner-manual Daybreak only after a valid exact-ref #19 APPROVE. No #21, no reset, no automatic Daybreak, no merge or closure.Review #19 execution record / no verdict
An ordinary whole-PR review was dispatched through the fresh visible Agent Manager session
ses_e9c6dcfdfffe7gNTPvpYArh2Ztat the exact frozen objects in reservation comment #18379: HEADa0e5a99afead71bfb5a4adf8fdd1a0c5429bf531, base/merge-basecd8fb16b62472b0c4a437a33718c84bbeaaa0ea8. The native transcript contains two queued prompt requests (amr_16394c691001cgB8LFv7OB3TXcandamr_16397a216001FHTHR0dMUOJwiG) but no assistant reviewer output, structured verdict, findings, checks, UX assessment or approval. Agent Manager showed the session retrying and then idle. Record this as a failed/unverified review attempt, not COMMENT, REQUEST_CHANGES or APPROVE; preserve both request references and do not retry in this session.The owner-authorized #174 maximum20 and role allocation remain in comment #18355. #20 is still owner-manual Daybreak only after a valid ordinary #19 APPROVE; no Daybreak was started, and no #21 is authorized. Because the ordinary result is absent, do not merge, close, or claim acceptance. The exact Agent Manager result-return failure will be addressed in #205's supported handoff workflow; this issue remains open pending an owner-authorized next review path if the failure consumed the available ordinary allocation.
kilo referenced this issue2026-10-22 15:19:05 +00:00
kilo referenced this issue2026-10-22 22:05:22 +00:00
2026-10-24 owner-directed reconciliation is proceeding independently of #205/#185. Current PR204 HEAD
a0e5a99afead71bfb5a4adf8fdd1a0c5429bf531; current developb2b35bce6678ebc4e393e8c5d78f8c1044f4b119. Canonical acceptance, all15 changed paths and exact consumer/retained-requirement/admission/dispatch tests were inspected; the existing54 producer tests pass. Existing exact resource/provider/model/opaque-variant/effort, current authority, refusal/no-substitution, backwards-compatible opt-in protocol and separate installed-consumer/live-acceptance boundaries are retained. No dependency on #205 or #185 is invented.A concrete integration defect is being corrected: unintegrated #174 producer D-078 collides with the now-integrated governing D-078 from #216. Renumber only the still-unintegrated producer decision to D-079, update its execution-surface references and add a uniqueness/reference regression. Accepted D-078 remains untouched; no executable semantics, service or reviewer machinery change. Full branch and exact predicted-merge validation follow.
Actual review #19 remains failed/unverified (comment #18387), not APPROVE; all#1-19 history persists. Conditional #20 remains owner-manual Daybreak only after valid ordinary approval on identical refs, hence ineligible. The new directive grants reconciliation/validation but no additional numbered reviews, #21/reset or waived security acceptance. No merge/closure or live Kernel/harness acceptance is claimed.
Reconciliation published normally as
f9ba72b2b891e50327cbe8c22f0a6ae165398e5a: producer decision D-079 + references/guard only, no change to executable semantics or accepted D-078. Focused exact contract55; combined executable/continuation/public-interface129; full branch make check2908/17skips; basedpyright0; package-check; working/staged/full-range whitespace PASS.Exact conflict-free predicted merge against develop
b2b35bce6678ebc4e393e8c5d78f8c1044f4b119is tree2e60afdcc52abaca3afe16c17b5fd69fa6f02001; full make check2910/17skips, basedpyright0, package-check PASS in an exact transient archive. No extra isolation for review, inference, live effects or real credentials. All15 accepted-scope effective changed paths inspected. Existing exact requirements/identity/effort/current authorization/refusal/public-interface behavior is retained; the previously reported fixture failure does not reproduce at these branch/integrated objects, so no unrelated fixture change was invented.Implemented+validated, NOT approved/merged/consumer-accepted. #19 remains failed/unverified; conditional #20 remains owner-manual/ineligible; no #21/reset or new review. #175 is integrated; #205/#185 do not gate upstream implementation, and Kernel #52/real-harness receipts remain separately scoped consumer acceptance. PR body now records exact current refs and remaining gates. Continuing fresh canonical /loop selection rather than stopping unrelated work on this issue-local owner-only gate.
Direct owner finite allocation admitted — 2026-10-24T18:38:51Z
Original authority is Adrian's direct USER message titled “Scarcity Router — Owner Authorization: Final Review and Integration of #209 and #204”, present in primary native conversation
ses_ea0104bd7ffe24sCWNMxA400MAat the timestamp above. This Kilo-authored canonical receipt is not itself owner authorship. It preserves an exact attested excerpt from that original message; no unavailable source file/history reconstruction is used.Verified canonical identity: repository BioMedical-IT/scarcity-router, database15; Issue174 database1382; linked PR204 database848, BioMedical-IT/scarcity-router#204. Fresh develop
57cef8275b766a6ecf678db83ea88767b061aa21contains integrated D-069A and current D-078. Current candidatef9ba72b2b891e50327cbe8c22f0a6ae165398e5a, merge-basecd8fb16b62472b0c4a437a33718c84bbeaaa0ea8. This finite exception cannot transfer to another delivery or change defaults.SHA-256 of the following exact UTF-8 excerpt, WITHOUT terminal newline:
7d9f11563c8ad76574033d35421e31aeca55ed66d3b44bedf0a5a324b4a08288.All actual #1-19 outcomes persist; #19's no-native-verdict execution record remains failed/unverified in comment18387, not an approval. #20 stays UNUSED and its former conditional allocation is superseded, not executed or relabeled as consumed. #21 is authorized but NOT reserved/dispatched: current-base effective-merged validation and native source preflight precede its exact freeze. #22 stays pending/ineligible until valid exact-current #21 APPROVE; only Adrian invokes official Codex
gpt-daybreak-blue-latest. No23+, reset, stale approval, automatic security review, forced integration or public-contract weakening. No production changes just to create another review; one consolidated owner handoff follows both eligible ordinary phases.Consolidated owner handoff — eligible ordinary work complete
This is the single consolidated participation handoff after both authorized ordinary reviews, the actual new209 finding, its autonomous correction and full CURRENT-base validation. No repeat request for the already-used15/21 allocations. Both PRs remain OPEN/UNMERGED; no Daybreak, main, release or deploy was invoked.
4d6bf51ce1/57cef8275b/79795ec999f9ba72b2b8/57cef8275b/cd8fb16b62Both fresh ordinary native sessions were explicitly catalog-resolved GPT-6.1 Sol/openai/high, no hidden substitution/backend-identity inference; final JSONs retrieved directly, no owner relay.209 session
ses_e90af415bffe3QDMat4VQkM2Gf/PR18758;204 sessionses_e909a02fdffewLJtS51oNjDgn9/PR18762. Raw-primary-Git reliance where shell denied and separate live/consumer/security scope were honestly retained, not erased. Direct owner native source/digests/budget admission: Issue18518747 and Issue17418740. Old14/20 remain superseded UNUSED, all actual historical outcomes unchanged.Owner action now: only eligible security #22 for PR204
Open a FRESH session in official Codex on the existing repository, visibly choose
gpt-daybreak-blue-latest, and use the following read-only task. Do not use Kilo, a launch script, substitute model or retired206 wrapper. Do NOT run209#16: its ordinary precondition is unmet.Retain official-binary provenance, explicit requested-model dispatch, native session/turn/input/output plus source/context/tool audit and actual identity observability under the existing Router policy. A model mismatch/substitution FAILS; unsupported/missing required evidence leaves the gate open. Return the native session/turn reference and structured result, not credentials or a large copied transcript. Backend-unobservable handling is only the existing bounded accepted policy, not a new weakening.
Remaining209 authority and safe sequencing
209's exact new decision/recovery/choices contract is Issue185 comment18772: the new source needs fresh whole-PR ordinary acceptance, but15 is consumed REQUEST_CHANGES and16 is manual-only conditional on15APPROVE. Tests, a consultation or a narrow verification cannot close it. Hold209 open or grant a NEW explicit finite issue-specific ordinary/security allocation including unused16 disposition; no ordinal is guessed/reserved/dispatched.
Prefer completing/verifying204#22 and integrating204 first when all gates remain satisfied, then freezing/validating209 against the resulting develop for any newly authorized review. Merging either changes the other's base; no current approval can silently transfer across that change. Neither conditional16 nor23+ may be borrowed. No architecture/permission/reviewer infrastructure reset is needed. Both corrected/source refs and exact canonical histories remain available; no scope is dropped to close an old PR.
Direct owner exception: Kilo security and automatic develop integration
Original authority: Adrian's direct USER message “Scarcity Router — Owner Decision: Complete #204 and #209 Without Daybreak”, native primary session
ses_ea0104bd7ffe24sCWNMxA400MA, 2026-10-24T21:55:32Z. This Kilo-authored receipt attests the original source; it is not itself owner authorship. Verified exact canonical Repo15 BioMedical-IT/scarcity-router / Issue174 database1382 / linked PR204 database848. Fresh develop57cef8275b766a6ecf678db83ea88767b061aa21 includes integrated D069A/D078; current HEADf9ba72b2b891e50327cbe8c22f0a6ae165398e5a/base57cef82/merge-basecd8fb16/effective2bc08acc are unchanged, so ordinary21APPROVE (18762) remains applicable.Exact shared binding excerpt SHA256
aa535747e122f4c4914fe65e87b91293ed53c316ac5d722090b817523784ac31; exact delivery excerpt SHA256a666a832c9bfff20f4da1cc0081caf959084c6b607e16fcb4e4d704e1a74a915. Digests are UTF-8 of each fenced excerpt WITHOUT terminal newline.Admitted effect only here: supersede UNUSED manual role22, without executing/emulating Daybreak or resetting any consumed result. New22 is native independent Kilo SECURITY, initially unconsumed/not yet dispatched; maximum24/no25+. If source/base corrections invalidate21, next authorized23/24 must freshly cover full correctness AND security; no stale approval. Explicit security assessment required; tests/generic COMMENT do not satisfy it. Preserve all prior outcomes and superseded unused20. This is separate direct owner security-path authority plus D069A finite-budget admission, not a claim D069A universally permits substituting manual gates.
Current exact validation2924/17skips,129focused,basedpyright0,package/whitespace remains PASS on unchanged2bc08acc; no unnecessary test rerun/code edit for review. Supported native source GET access already actually verified at technical preflight
ses_e90c3533dffexKBP5JdllG3WEWand full21 session; profile/refs unchanged. Use existing read-only D078 session/pinned-source/Git-proof path, no new environment/permissions/framework/206 resurrection. Prefer204 first; after valid exact-current explicit securityAPPROVE and all acceptance, canonical /loop merge into develop, verify integrated result, then validate209 on that NEW base. No main/release/deploy or owner routine relay. Other deliveries retain their original security policies.Producer delivery integrated and acceptance verified
PR204 merged canonically into develop at
c38c8ae5390e27b9bfb9ae210b76d6efa89a2d36(2026-10-24T22:24:15Z), under exact direct owner21:55:32Z exception18779 and /loop authority. Verified merge parents are approved base57cef8275b766a6ecf678db83ea88767b061aa21and approved HEADf9ba72b2b891e50327cbe8c22f0a6ae165398e5a; HEAD is ancestor and integrated tree is byte-identical to approved/validated effective tree2bc08acc44cdd18fa578c0d2229b00b255b3667b. Current checkout fast-forwarded cleanly. Measured integration stat is15files/1883additions/21deletions; earlier summary15deletions was a count typo, not a missing hunk/source change: exact reviewed e0924ec8 effective patch/tree is unchanged.Accepted evidence: ordinary21APPROVE18762 plus fresh explicit independent Kilo SECURITY22APPROVE/findings[]/limitations[]18784, native session
ses_e90070208ffegl0JhXbsvQL0On, GPT-6.1 Sol/openai/high dispatch.22 consumed as the new authorized Kilo security role; no Daybreak launched/emulated and no global policy change;23-24 not used, all prior outcomes retained.AC1: D079/execution-surface distinguish model recommendation from exact executable selection; actual pin/parser, opaque variant/nullable effort/provenance/context preserved by the supported helper.
AC2-4: actual producer/helper/admission/synthetic-adapter positive chain, negative authorization/profile/state/identity/tool/protocol/binding/refusal/continuation cases; no selection reservation/inference, current exact admission, no rerank/repair/substitution or physical-observation claim.
AC5: frozen recommendation and legacy gateway compatibility, existing listener and automatic helper/final validation, no second service/ranker/manual copying.
AC6: pinned Kernel73e3af45 source mapping, producer-consumer synthetic conformance and separately authorized real-harness recipe delivered. Exact premerge full2924/17skips, both type gates0, package checks and whitespace PASS; POST-MERGE integrated129 executable/continuation/frozen-interface tests also PASS on the identical tree.
Closing the accepted Router PRODUCER delivery as integrated, not declaring installed Kernel/harness/product GO. Kernel52 and existing #181 retain the separately authorized real-harness/physical-model/live/billing acceptance; no real inference, deployment, release, main promotion, Kernel mutation or requirement deletion occurred. Known stateless unsupported-harness stripping boundary stays explicit. Next, independently reconcile209 against actual NEW developc38c8ae, not stale57cef82 approval/testing.
kilo referenced this issue2026-10-25 09:31:28 +00:00