Expose executable recommendations with exact retained requirements (#174) #204
No reviewers
Labels
No labels
accessibility
bug
documentation
duplicate
enhancement
good first issue
help wanted
invalid
P1
P2
P3
question
wontfix
No milestone
No project
No assignees
2 participants
Notifications
Due date
No due date set.
Dependencies
No dependencies set.
Reference
Creatidy/scarcity-router!204
Loading…
Add table
Add a link
Reference in a new issue
No description provided.
Delete branch "issue-174-executable-contract"
Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?
Refs #174. MERGED into develop; accepted Router producer delivery closed. Installed Kernel/harness/live/physical-model/billing acceptance remains separately scoped, not claimed.
Accepted Source And Integration
Reviewed HEAD
f9ba72b2b891e50327cbe8c22f0a6ae165398e5a, base57cef8275b766a6ecf678db83ea88767b061aa21, merge-basecd8fb16b62472b0c4a437a33718c84bbeaaa0ea8; effective tree2bc08acc44cdd18fa578c0d2229b00b255b3667b. Canonical mergec38c8ae5390e27b9bfb9ae210b76d6efa89a2d36has exactly those two parents and byte-identical approved tree. Full15-path/1883-addition/21-deletion actual delta; earlier summary15deletions corrected without any source/fingerprint change. Native effective patchSHAe0924ec80cb65c830a373696c74f618b3837f11ad494574a25973b2d68f00175.Functionality And Boundaries
Additive authenticated executable recommendation on existing gateway, exact resource/provider/model/opaque variant/catalog effort plus retained quality/structural/profile/output controls. Selection does not infer/reserve quota/dispatch; actual current authority/state/adapters/limits govern exact admission, no rerank/substitution. Consumer helper/final outbound validation and continuation preserve bindings without manual copying/repair. Legacy/frozen interfaces, credential/public projection, D078/U015 and accepted functionality remain intact. D079 records producer scope; installed Kernel52/#181/real-harness/live/observed billing/identity are not passed by synthetic fixtures or PR closure. No second service/inventory/grant/cache authority, workspace expansion or cross-repo mutation.
Actual Independent Acceptance
Ordinary21 APPROVE (18762) plus fresh native Kilo SECURITY22 explicit APPROVE/findings[]/limitations[] (18784), session
ses_e90070208ffegl0JhXbsvQL0On, GPT-6.1 Sol/openai/high dispatch. Complete actual source/diff independently inspected, no implementation-context transfer, owner relay or backend-self-report assumption. Source frozen; exact canonical labels/refs/cleanliness and AC1-6 rechecked immediately before supported merge.22 consumed;23-24 unused; all previous outcomes preserved.Direct owner USER2026-10-24T21:55:32Z scoped exception18779 explicitly superseded unused manual22 and Daybreak only for204/209, requiring independent Kilo security and autonomous /loop acceptance/integration. No Daybreak was invoked/emulated and unrelated global security policy remains unchanged. No new reviewer framework/permissions/environment,206 resurrection, main/release/deploy.
Validation / Completion Evidence
Exact premerge current-tree make check2924/17skips;129focused; repo+standalone basedpyright0; all package checks; whitespace PASS, synthetic env only. Postmerge actual129 producer/continuation/frozen-interface tests PASS on identical tree. Integrated ancestry/tree and scoped acceptance/closure evidence: Issue17418789. Issue174 closed2026-10-24T22:28:21Z for producer delivery, no product GO.
STOP_REVISE, no merge. ExactHEAD8409d5da6665f04c531a0d4f7879b74184f51168/baseedd31326d4abe5cc282adb419cb54c78d4677ec4. Ordinary ordinal8 APPROVE; required direct-Codex gpt-daybreak-blue-latest ordinal9 REQUEST_CHANGES. Verified P1 adapter_unavailable missing from admission-accepted exclusion vocabulary -> actual retired-adapter exact admission raises RouteContractValidationError instead of typed503, no dispatch. P2 authoritative Requests allowlist omits execution_requirements. Latest fullgate2823/17skips/type0/exit0 PASS; tests do not establish those untested negative guarantees.
Review budget9/10: fixes need fresh ordinary AND additional exact Daybreak (two more), onlyone remains. No sourcepatch/approval weakening/combined gate/review11/reset permitted; preserving currentcleanbranch/openPR. No installed Kernel/harness/physicalidentity/live/billing acceptance claimed. Issue174 terminal ledger preserves all ordinals and real source evidence.
STOP_REVISE at owner-local12reviewceiling, no merge. ExactHEAD07667d8e269529039ede003d52a1f5a635663cd3/baseedd31326d4abe5cc282adb419cb54c78d4677ec4, clean nine ordinary scoped commits. Full2826/type0 gates PASS; original vocabulary/worker/sorting and documentation parity findings fixed. Ordinary10APPROVE; required official directCodex11REQUEST_CHANGES for new public unroutable_identities authorization-projection disclosure. Final12unchanged-source expanded-authority adjudication failedCLIinputlength beforeturn/start, no approval; preservefailedordinal/no13. Existing source kept unchanged afterreviews, no fabricatedacceptance or counterreset. Cannot merge/close/advance another issue while selected delivery lacks mandatory security approval.
kilo referenced this pull request2026-10-10 22:49:50 +00:00
Direct owner exception admitted for exact Issue174/PR204 in canonical issue comment18740: original primary native USER message2026-10-24T18:38:51Z, session
ses_ea0104bd7ffe24sCWNMxA400MA, exact attested excerpt SHA2567d9f11563c8ad76574033d35421e31aeca55ed66d3b44bedf0a5a324b4a08288. Integrated D-069A verified on freshly fetched develop57cef82. NEW finite maximum22: all actual1-19 outcomes unchanged; unused old conditional20 superseded without execution/reclassification; ordinary21 only after current-base full validation/exact freeze/source preflight; owner-manual official Codex Daybreak22 only after valid21APPROVE; no23+. Older no21 allocation text is superseded, not security/currentness/default limits. No formal review dispatched/reserved yet.Existing native execution record18387 proves19 produced no reviewer verdict; it remains failed/unverified, not COMMENT or APPROVE. Do not restart that session or old diagnostics. Current candidatef9ba72b/base57cef82/merge-basecd8fb16; recompute/test exact effective integration, preserving D078/#216 and #217 rather than claiming
b2b35bcresults prove it.Reserve imminent NEW ordinary independent review #21 under exact owner maximum22 (Issue174 receipt18740, direct native USER2026-10-24T18:38:51Z in primary
ses_ea0104bd7ffe24sCWNMxA400MA, excerpt digest7d9f11563c8ad76574033d35421e31aeca55ed66d3b44bedf0a5a324b4a08288). Correct canonical repo15/Issue1382/PR848 identity and integrated D069A reverified. Actual1-19 history preserved; old20 superseded UNUSED, no execution/reclassification; manual22 pending/ineligible until21APPROVE, no23+.Freeze HEAD
f9ba72b2b891e50327cbe8c22f0a6ae165398e5a, current base57cef8275b766a6ecf678db83ea88767b061aa21, merge-basecd8fb16b62472b0c4a437a33718c84bbeaaa0ea8, effective tree2bc08acc44cdd18fa578c0d2229b00b255b3667b. Complete15-path delta inspected. All14 non-decision canonical/effective patches byte-identical (full-index SHA256e38d25437514e87356662094977559ce76aa26c5466269a6aea1b6f190b31aef); their postimages equal pinned HEAD. Actual effective decisions.md hunk is supplied directly from current-base Git diff, preserving current D078/U015; full effective patch SHA256e0924ec80cb65c830a373696c74f618b3837f11ad494574a25973b2d68f00175.Current-base gates PASS on exacttree2bc08acc: locked dev sync;129 focused exact-contract/continuation/interface tests; full2924/17skips; repo+standalone basedpyright0; all package checks; whitespace. Primary source/refs clean and unchanged; no production edit to create review. Native technical-only source preflight
ses_e90c3533dffexKBP5JdllG3WEWpassed exact metadata/pinned getter access without ordinal. Fresh native user-visible read-only dispatch explicitly selects supported GPT-6.1 Sol/openai/high, not assumed main brand/implicit Highspeed/fallback/backend verification. Only task/AC/refs/contracts/complete source instructions and raw native Git evidence, no implementation conversation/desired verdict. Review is ordinary, not Daybreak. Source remains frozen; owner participation consolidated after both eligible phases.Ordinary review #21 — APPROVE; manual #22 pending
Actual fresh native read-only session
ses_e909a02fdffewLJtS51oNjDgn9; explicit native dispatch resolved GPT-6.1 Sol/openai/high, no implicit Highspeed/fallback or independently verified backend-identity claim. Final JSON retrieved natively, no owner relay. Verdict APPROVE, findings=[] on exact HEADf9ba72b2b891e50327cbe8c22f0a6ae165398e5a, base57cef8275b766a6ecf678db83ea88767b061aa21, merge-basecd8fb16b62472b0c4a437a33718c84bbeaaa0ea8, effective tree2bc08acc44cdd18fa578c0d2229b00b255b3667b. Primary re-read canonical PR and native clean/ref evidence after result: identical, no source mutation or findings.Reviewer independently inspected all15 paths/all14 bounded per-file diffs, every1115-line executable test region through pinned slices, changed implementations/unchanged context and the complete actual effective decisions.md addition. Assessed exact identity/nullable effort/opaque variants, retained quality/profile/output controls, coherent current authority/adapters, exact admission/no rerank, privacy, continuation, compatibility and UX. UX: existing listener plus consumer helper avoids manual pin copying; final loss refuses rather than repairs; no material regression identified.
Limitations retained, not erased: (1) shell unavailable; effective-tree/hash mapping relies on supplied actual native primary Git evidence while canonical source/all changed regions/effective doc hunk were independently inspected; (2) ordinary approval is not manual Daybreak, installed Kernel/harness/live/billing/physical-model acceptance. These are provenance/scope boundaries, not an unresolved source/correctness finding. No reviewer-run tests claimed. Primary current-base129focused +2924full/17skips, both type gates0, package and whitespace PASS remain exact-current.
Reserve new owner-manual official Codex
gpt-daybreak-blue-latestsecurity ordinal #22 against these unchanged refs under direct owner receipt18740. #21 consumed APPROVE; old20 remains superseded UNUSED; all1-19 history intact; no23+ or stale/base-transfer authority. #22 is RESERVED/UNCONSUMED and may only be actually invoked by Adrian through official Codex, never Kilo/script. READY_FOR_OWNER_SECURITY_REVIEW, NOT READY_TO_MERGE. Consolidated owner handoff will follow the other delivery's authorized remediation; no participation requested yet.Reserve imminent NEW native Kilo independent SECURITY review #22 under direct owner21:55:32Z exception admitted in Issue17418779 (shared binding SHA256
aa535747e122f4c4914fe65e87b91293ed53c316ac5d722090b817523784ac31, exact204 allocationa666a832c9bfff20f4da1cc0081caf959084c6b607e16fcb4e4d704e1a74a915, original source current primary USER/sessionses_ea0104bd7ffe24sCWNMxA400MA). This explicitly supersedes only UNUSED manual22 role; it is not a Daybreak invocation/emulation, consumed-result reuse or generic policy change. Ordinary21APPROVE remains at identical refs. New maximum24, fresh23-24 after corrections authorized; no25+.Freeze HEAD
f9ba72b2b891e50327cbe8c22f0a6ae165398e5a, base57cef8275b766a6ecf678db83ea88767b061aa21, merge-basecd8fb16b62472b0c4a437a33718c84bbeaaa0ea8, effective tree2bc08acc44cdd18fa578c0d2229b00b255b3667b. Fresh actual Git/canonical clean refs/effective patchSHAe0924ec80cb65c830a373696c74f618b3837f11ad494574a25973b2d68f00175verified unchanged. Complete15-path source, not corrective-only subset. Existing exact current-tree129focused/2924full17skips/type0/package/whitespace PASS remains applicable, not tests-as-security or historicalb2b35bcsubstitution.Native current selectable-agent preflight
ses_e9010b975ffeqXkc4MGRcAoGOmcreated prepared pr-reviewer with NO prompt/inference/ordinal then closed; same unchanged modeall/read-only profile/source GET route was actually exercised in prior technical preflight and full21. No permission/source-access redesign. Fresh22 explicitly selects catalog-supported GPT-6.1 Sol/openai/high: capable for security-critical code/auth analysis and known supported native route, not Highspeed/implicit fallback/prestige-only choice or inferred backend identity. New read-only conversation gets task/AC/refs/contracts/raw Git/source instructions and the legitimate scoped owner exception only; no implementation conversation/internal reasoning/desired verdict. Explicit security assessment, material findings/limitations and UX required; genericCOMMENT/tests do not approve security.Source stays frozen for whole review. Native automated final-result collection, no owner relay. On exact current explicit securityAPPROVE plus all acceptance, owner-authorized canonical /loop integration into develop proceeds autonomously; otherwise substantiate/fix/test/fresh authorized23-24 (combined correctness+security if21 invalidated). No global/manual gate change for other deliveries,206 resurrection,new reviewer environment,main/release/deploy.
Native independent SECURITY #22 — APPROVE
Actual fresh read-only session
ses_e90070208ffegl0JhXbsvQL0On, explicit native dispatch GPT-6.1 Sol/openai/high; no implicit fallback, owner relay or independently verified serving-backend claim. Final native JSON retrieved automatically. review_kind=independent_security; overall verdict=APPROVE; security_assessment.verdict=APPROVE; findings=[]; limitations=[]. Exact HEADf9ba72b2b891e50327cbe8c22f0a6ae165398e5a, base57cef8275b766a6ecf678db83ea88767b061aa21, merge-basecd8fb16b62472b0c4a437a33718c84bbeaaa0ea8, effective tree2bc08acc44cdd18fa578c0d2229b00b255b3667b.Reviewer independently inspected all15 effective paths/every patch, all1115 added test lines in pinned slices, actual current-base decision addition and material auth/JSON/publication/admission/continuation dependencies. Explicit security assessment covered current client/admin/profile grant intersection and coherent published application; exact resource/provider/model/opaque variant/nullable catalog effort; demand-not-authority context; quality/profile/structural/output constraints and final helper validation; current exact admission/final dispatch and continuation reauthorization; bounded input/refusal, credential/private projection, no provider metadata/tool/workspace escalation. No material defect or unresolved blocking security uncertainty. UX: additive existing listener and automatic binding/final refusal, no material regression.
Checks honestly retain that primary supplied actual local Git/effective-tree fingerprint proof; canonical source/currentness and changed regions independently retrieved. One Git probe denied; no bypass, guessed result or source omission. Reviewer ran no tests/provider/model calls/platform writes; full exact2924/17skip/type/package gates are primary validation, not independent security proof. Native final assessment does NOT claim installed Kernel/harness/live/physical/billing acceptance.
Ordinary21APPROVE still matches identical refs.22 is now consumed as actual KILO SECURITY under exact owner21:55:32Z exception18779; old unused manual22 role was superseded, not executed/emulated or reused as consumed. Other histories/default/global security policies unchanged;23-24 remain unused authorized contingencies/no25+. No Daybreak dependency remains for this exact delivery. Source stayed frozen. Proceeding only to fresh canonical labels/refs/cleanliness/all producer acceptance checks, then supported /loop develop merge and integrated verification; no main/release/deploy.
kilo referenced this pull request2026-10-25 11:07:17 +00:00