Verify installed MI Router explicit-input acceptance #42

Merged
kilo merged 1 commit from issue-19-installed-router into develop 2026-10-26 09:29:46 +00:00
Member

Refs #19.

Owner continuation 2026-10-26 resumes the existing loop for installed deterministic MI→Router explicit-input acceptance, permits original controlled synthetic public evidence for a positive case and separately requires selected #15 source compatibility findings. It excludes D-082 active admission, default MI activation, Kernel #55/Console prerequisites, live provider/authentication/inference, deployment/release and product GO. Integration/closure applies only to genuinely verified installed scope under exact independent-review/currentness gates.

Frozen implementation base d65891668b; candidate 0b549d20e1. Installed MI remains exactly Router's optional pin d65891668b; installed Router4162f6fa9f774beaf6e92d86b7ebc92f306da4bd (merged #176/PR221). No production library/schema/dependency/foreign-repository changes.

Adds a bounded external-process installed conformance runner and retained acceptance receipt (INSTALLED_ACCEPTANCE.md), with exact canonical archives, wheel/sdist SHA256s, byte-identical rebuilds, hash-enforced local-wheel optional-dependency installation, installed metadata/module/file provenance and outside-source imports. Base Router selects with MI absent. Actual installed MI publish/reader→Router load→shared selector consumes 4096-token positive explanation before evaluation; update during collection preserves cutA, next decision uses8192/cutB. Actual machine envelope/accepted MI verifier binds immutable cut/time/context/decision/manifest; retained A replays identically after B. Explanation-only authority preserved.

Validation: secret-safe offline make check PASS178, zero typing errors/warnings, Ruff/locked-sync/whitespace PASS; installed62 maintained tests (16Router+46MI), 9explicit refusals,6binding-tamper refusals,12MI+73Router module comparisons; installed CLI status=inspect=export=reader; current packaging/historical four-mode installed lifecycle PASS46 and three equal current wheels. Clean committed rerun receipt being captured at /tmp/kilo/mi19-installed-0b549d2; full prior successful receipt /tmp/kilo/mi19-installed-fifth.

Actual installed zai.normalize+publish+consumer.load succeeds with complete original upstream-shaped captures but cannot provide a positive exact Router fact: null scope channel, no subject configuration/effort, unknown freshness;25existing model-identity pairings cannot repair applicability. This is explicitly a selected-source adoption limitation, not fabricated positive source proof. No channel/effort/physical identity/curation invented. Kernel/Console, live/provider acceptance, full A/B/C value, final release/product GO remain unaccepted/unverified. No Daybreak run.

Fresh independent whole-PR review pending; review counter0/10 recovered from existing ledger. No merge before exact approval and all loop gates.

Refs #19. Owner continuation 2026-10-26 resumes the existing loop for installed deterministic MI→Router explicit-input acceptance, permits original controlled synthetic public evidence for a positive case and separately requires selected #15 source compatibility findings. It excludes D-082 active admission, default MI activation, Kernel #55/Console prerequisites, live provider/authentication/inference, deployment/release and product GO. Integration/closure applies only to genuinely verified installed scope under exact independent-review/currentness gates. Frozen implementation base d65891668b7e79f7b666c021f02a1b4bf8c4ca9c; candidate 0b549d20e191698941913e4a1fe9ff73eff8af45. Installed MI remains exactly Router's optional pin d65891668b7e79f7b666c021f02a1b4bf8c4ca9c; installed Router4162f6fa9f774beaf6e92d86b7ebc92f306da4bd (merged #176/PR221). No production library/schema/dependency/foreign-repository changes. Adds a bounded external-process installed conformance runner and retained acceptance receipt (INSTALLED_ACCEPTANCE.md), with exact canonical archives, wheel/sdist SHA256s, byte-identical rebuilds, hash-enforced local-wheel optional-dependency installation, installed metadata/module/file provenance and outside-source imports. Base Router selects with MI absent. Actual installed MI publish/reader→Router load→shared selector consumes 4096-token positive explanation before evaluation; update during collection preserves cutA, next decision uses8192/cutB. Actual machine envelope/accepted MI verifier binds immutable cut/time/context/decision/manifest; retained A replays identically after B. Explanation-only authority preserved. Validation: secret-safe offline make check PASS178, zero typing errors/warnings, Ruff/locked-sync/whitespace PASS; installed62 maintained tests (16Router+46MI), 9explicit refusals,6binding-tamper refusals,12MI+73Router module comparisons; installed CLI status=inspect=export=reader; current packaging/historical four-mode installed lifecycle PASS46 and three equal current wheels. Clean committed rerun receipt being captured at /tmp/kilo/mi19-installed-0b549d2; full prior successful receipt /tmp/kilo/mi19-installed-fifth. Actual installed zai.normalize+publish+consumer.load succeeds with complete original upstream-shaped captures but cannot provide a positive exact Router fact: null scope channel, no subject configuration/effort, unknown freshness;25existing model-identity pairings cannot repair applicability. This is explicitly a selected-source adoption limitation, not fabricated positive source proof. No channel/effort/physical identity/curation invented. Kernel/Console, live/provider acceptance, full A/B/C value, final release/product GO remain unaccepted/unverified. No Daybreak run. Fresh independent whole-PR review pending; review counter0/10 recovered from existing ledger. No merge before exact approval and all loop gates.
kilo merged commit 8f572c332d into develop 2026-10-26 09:29:46 +00:00
Author
Member

Final loop result supersedes the initial pending-review paragraph: review1 COMMENT/findings[] for restricted evidence/execution toolset; fresh authorized native equivalent review2 APPROVE/findings[]/limitations[] for exactHEAD0b549d20e191698941913e4a1fe9ff73eff8af45/base d65891668b. Independent reviewer reran sanitized make check178, installed conformance62+9refusals+6bindingtamper and packaging lifecycle46; documented hashes reproduced.

Supported MCP merge produced8f572c332db8290b5dad9e03f5b0f960271a8349. Fresh canonical Git/MCP verification confirms both expected parents/approvedHEAD ancestry and integrated tree identical to approved candidate. Issue19 completion/limitations evidence: #19 (comment) ; actual closed state verified. Same checkout safely fast-forwarded to clean current develop; issue branch/history preserved.

Installed deterministic explicit-input scope passed, not selected-source positive adoption, live activation, D082, Kernel/Console completion, public release or product GO. Fresh exhaustive MI queue now contains only #3/#5/#7, each exactly labeled invalid and excluded before historical PR/gate interpretation; no eligible or UNVERIFIED issue remains. No speculative issue creation or foreign mutation.

Final loop result supersedes the initial pending-review paragraph: review1 COMMENT/findings[] for restricted evidence/execution toolset; fresh authorized native equivalent review2 APPROVE/findings[]/limitations[] for exactHEAD0b549d20e191698941913e4a1fe9ff73eff8af45/base d65891668b7e79f7b666c021f02a1b4bf8c4ca9c. Independent reviewer reran sanitized make check178, installed conformance62+9refusals+6bindingtamper and packaging lifecycle46; documented hashes reproduced. Supported MCP merge produced8f572c332db8290b5dad9e03f5b0f960271a8349. Fresh canonical Git/MCP verification confirms both expected parents/approvedHEAD ancestry and integrated tree identical to approved candidate. Issue19 completion/limitations evidence: https://forgejo.creatidy.com/Creatidy/model-intelligence/issues/19#issuecomment-18976 ; actual closed state verified. Same checkout safely fast-forwarded to clean current develop; issue branch/history preserved. Installed deterministic explicit-input scope passed, not selected-source positive adoption, live activation, D082, Kernel/Console completion, public release or product GO. Fresh exhaustive MI queue now contains only #3/#5/#7, each exactly labeled invalid and excluded before historical PR/gate interpretation; no eligible or UNVERIFIED issue remains. No speculative issue creation or foreign mutation.
Sign in to join this conversation.
No reviewers
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference
Creatidy/model-intelligence!42
No description provided.