Creatidy/model-intelligence
5
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull requests Projects Releases Packages Wiki Activity Actions

Align MI evidence architecture and register the integration roadmap #20

Merged
adrian.tkacz merged 3 commits from issue-11-shared-architecture into develop 2026-10-05 07:07:56 +00:00
Conversation 3 Commits 3 Files changed 6 +525 -16
kilo commented 2026-10-04 22:37:23 +00:00
Member
Copy link

Refs #11

Frozen Documentation Delivery

Canonical base/merge base: fb7299810fdc4612d4e0559465faef571662c6ef.
Current HEAD: 019082e8e42ede3a9173a4622a055390c92e0fa0.
Initial delivery: 3925e59877d5a3d7d9bda3161796790d470e388e.
First remediation: 4381d242f072a01b7aa6fae6c1114c1a42abc8b1.
Owner-selected terminology-only correction: 019082e8e42ede3a9173a4622a055390c92e0fa0.
Three ordinary Adrian-authored additive commits, pushed on the same issue-11-shared-architecture branch/PR. Clean ordinary checkout, canonical refs and full base delta verified. No worktree/history rewrite/merge/main/release/deploy.

Mandate and Source

Owner-selected English shared-architecture documentation/planning and deduplicated MI gap registration, not functional implementation. Source: v1.0 (2026-10-04), Creatidy_architektura_systemu_2026-10-04.md, owner-supplied SHA-256 4e64121599ac30896afb77574b2fd16cddfc3420afde37108611715c24b56e92, supplied MI section bundle 1–5, 7–10, 12–18. Full source not located in workspace or /tmp/kilo; the available brief informs #11/documents, not a claimed computed hash or invented finer source headings.
Owner merged #9/PR #10 during audit; this PR uses that updated base and preserves synthetic R2 and #1 real-source/value/rights STOP/GO gate. #3/PR #4 and #7/PR #8 remain unmerged STOP_REVISE; their history/budgets are not reset.

Six Documentation Files

README current-state/index; ARCHITECTURE shared roles/authority/privacy, Agreed/Verified/Proposed Clarification/To Prove, temporal limits/invariants, contracts/reuse/security and preserved decision history; ROADMAP full requirements/G01–G13 evidence-task matrix, prioritized registry and receipts; AGENTS plus task/discipline rules as short owner-document pointers. No standalone ADR existed or was removed.
No product/schema/test/dependency/lock/Makefile/native command/reviewer implementation changed. No unapproved API/flag/ontology/TTL/PKI/broker, copied upstream material, product inference/live task or secret/service/cost/permission/branch-protection change. No new NOTICE required.

Current Product Names and Remediation

Creatidy Kernel / creatidy-kernel owns intent, authority, WorkUnit/Attempt lifecycle, harness/workspace, verification/review/remediation/recovery/outcome evidence. Scarcity Router / scarcity-router owns execution resources/accounts/quota/availability/economics/selection/admission/provider gateway. MI owns external evidence/publication; Console owns views and authorized delegation.
The owner's subsequent terminology directive required removal of unnecessary historical naming explanations, not replacement with an alias/glossary or redesign. Corrected exactly one repository occurrence in ARCHITECTURE and the matching active explanation in issue #11 body. Both are classified as removed as unnecessary; surrounding responsibilities and no-renaming invariants remain unchanged. Full tracked/hidden exact, case-insensitive/Markdown/encoded/Unicode and broad current-text sweeps have zero matches at the committed HEAD. No source/config/test/fixture change or new component/API is needed.
Canonical discovery covered all 13 open issue bodies, three open PR bodies and 56 comments on those records plus designated historical records; only #11 body required a naming correction. No other existing issue/PR/comment needed terminology substitution. Old Git objects and closed historical records are not sanitized. Post-update canonical verification and fresh independent whole-PR review follow; no current approval is inferred from older SHA reviews.

Open Registered Work and Next Gate

#12 P1 licensed real-source A/B/C value/rights and owner decision; #13 P1 publication/evidence-cut/validity conformance; #14 P1 capability/limit identity-calibration boundary; #15 P2 permitted-source producer/complete publication after accepted #12–#14; #16 P2 operator state/events; #17 P2 separate optional privacy/benefit decision; #18 P2 public install/update/migrations; #19 P2 installed update/outage/unknown/withdrawal receipt. All remain open with positive/negative/failure criteria, non-goals/invariants, reuse/security/compatibility/diagnostics and future permissions. Dependencies are explicitly in bodies/comments; no claim of native dependency edges.
MI publication #13/#15 → Router #176 → Kernel #55 immutable utilized reference. MI #14 ↔ Router #175 + Kernel #49/#51; runtime #47/#52/#53 and Router #174/#178/#179/#181; separate state MI #16/Kernel #57/Router #183; local outcome Kernel #58→Router #177 versus optional MI #17; installed compatibility MI #18/#19 ↔ Kernel #62/#60 and Router #185/#186. Kernel review/budgets/concurrency/isolation remain its work, not MI.
Console counterparts were registered after the documentation lookup and are now recorded in MI #16 comment14308; that current contract evidence supersedes discovery-time absence notes, without claiming Console integration.
Next substantive MI work remains #12, not #15 production ingestion before proof/rights gate. No functional task selected or started.

Package Metadata Disposition

pyproject.toml:8 retains the pre-existing bootstrap summary. Owner-approved no-edit alternative is explicitly recorded in #18 comment14425: keep this reviewed documentation-only scope and correct installed/package metadata consistently under existing #18 acceptance or a separately owner-selected metadata-only delivery, with proper package validation/fresh review. It is acknowledged stale, not presented as true current product status. No packaging edit or wheel build is claimed here.

Validation and Review Ledger

Initial3925e59 native COMMENT → round1 normal4381d24 → fresh native APPROVE at4381d24. A further fresh read-only canonical verification at unchanged4381d24 also returned APPROVE. Owner then selected terminology correction019082e; remediation budget is now 2/3, not reset. All older head-specific approvals are historical; a fresh review of current019082e is required and pending at this description update.
Executed: UV_OFFLINE=1 make check PASS37 on corrected tree; locked sync, Ruff lint/format, basedpyright zero diagnostics, 35 R2 + two bootstrap tests, staged/unstaged whitespace. Full committed base-range whitespace and unchanged src/tests/Makefile/packaging/lock/native workflow checks PASS. Read-only scratch docs/registry checker PASS six ASCII docs/218 references/G01–G13 and actual consumer-link regressions. Exact/variant sweeps repeated successfully on committed019082e; whole-base semantic diff inspected.
Forgejo reported no workflow runs; no CI success or live integration claimed. Packaging unchanged, isolated wheel/build not rerun. Source bytes/digest and sibling implementation/deployment not independently verified. Native verdict and any formal Forgejo review remain distinct; no branch-protection requirement inferred. Documentation readiness is not product GO, READY_FOR_LIVE_TASK, merge or completion of functional gaps.

Refs #11 ## Frozen Documentation Delivery Canonical base/merge base: `fb7299810fdc4612d4e0559465faef571662c6ef`. Current HEAD: `019082e8e42ede3a9173a4622a055390c92e0fa0`. Initial delivery: `3925e59877d5a3d7d9bda3161796790d470e388e`. First remediation: `4381d242f072a01b7aa6fae6c1114c1a42abc8b1`. Owner-selected terminology-only correction: `019082e8e42ede3a9173a4622a055390c92e0fa0`. Three ordinary Adrian-authored additive commits, pushed on the same issue-11-shared-architecture branch/PR. Clean ordinary checkout, canonical refs and full base delta verified. No worktree/history rewrite/merge/main/release/deploy. ## Mandate and Source Owner-selected English shared-architecture documentation/planning and deduplicated MI gap registration, not functional implementation. Source: v1.0 (2026-10-04), `Creatidy_architektura_systemu_2026-10-04.md`, owner-supplied SHA-256 `4e64121599ac30896afb77574b2fd16cddfc3420afde37108611715c24b56e92`, supplied MI section bundle 1–5, 7–10, 12–18. Full source not located in workspace or /tmp/kilo; the available brief informs #11/documents, not a claimed computed hash or invented finer source headings. Owner merged #9/PR #10 during audit; this PR uses that updated base and preserves synthetic R2 and #1 real-source/value/rights STOP/GO gate. #3/PR #4 and #7/PR #8 remain unmerged STOP_REVISE; their history/budgets are not reset. ## Six Documentation Files README current-state/index; ARCHITECTURE shared roles/authority/privacy, Agreed/Verified/Proposed Clarification/To Prove, temporal limits/invariants, contracts/reuse/security and preserved decision history; ROADMAP full requirements/G01–G13 evidence-task matrix, prioritized registry and receipts; AGENTS plus task/discipline rules as short owner-document pointers. No standalone ADR existed or was removed. No product/schema/test/dependency/lock/Makefile/native command/reviewer implementation changed. No unapproved API/flag/ontology/TTL/PKI/broker, copied upstream material, product inference/live task or secret/service/cost/permission/branch-protection change. No new NOTICE required. ## Current Product Names and Remediation Creatidy Kernel / `creatidy-kernel` owns intent, authority, WorkUnit/Attempt lifecycle, harness/workspace, verification/review/remediation/recovery/outcome evidence. Scarcity Router / `scarcity-router` owns execution resources/accounts/quota/availability/economics/selection/admission/provider gateway. MI owns external evidence/publication; Console owns views and authorized delegation. The owner's subsequent terminology directive required removal of unnecessary historical naming explanations, not replacement with an alias/glossary or redesign. Corrected exactly one repository occurrence in ARCHITECTURE and the matching active explanation in issue #11 body. Both are classified as removed as unnecessary; surrounding responsibilities and no-renaming invariants remain unchanged. Full tracked/hidden exact, case-insensitive/Markdown/encoded/Unicode and broad current-text sweeps have zero matches at the committed HEAD. No source/config/test/fixture change or new component/API is needed. Canonical discovery covered all 13 open issue bodies, three open PR bodies and 56 comments on those records plus designated historical records; only #11 body required a naming correction. No other existing issue/PR/comment needed terminology substitution. Old Git objects and closed historical records are not sanitized. Post-update canonical verification and fresh independent whole-PR review follow; no current approval is inferred from older SHA reviews. ## Open Registered Work and Next Gate #12 P1 licensed real-source A/B/C value/rights and owner decision; #13 P1 publication/evidence-cut/validity conformance; #14 P1 capability/limit identity-calibration boundary; #15 P2 permitted-source producer/complete publication after accepted #12–#14; #16 P2 operator state/events; #17 P2 separate optional privacy/benefit decision; #18 P2 public install/update/migrations; #19 P2 installed update/outage/unknown/withdrawal receipt. All remain open with positive/negative/failure criteria, non-goals/invariants, reuse/security/compatibility/diagnostics and future permissions. Dependencies are explicitly in bodies/comments; no claim of native dependency edges. MI publication #13/#15 → Router #176 → Kernel #55 immutable utilized reference. MI #14 ↔ Router #175 + Kernel #49/#51; runtime #47/#52/#53 and Router #174/#178/#179/#181; separate state MI #16/Kernel #57/Router #183; local outcome Kernel #58→Router #177 versus optional MI #17; installed compatibility MI #18/#19 ↔ Kernel #62/#60 and Router #185/#186. Kernel review/budgets/concurrency/isolation remain its work, not MI. Console counterparts were registered after the documentation lookup and are now recorded in MI #16 comment14308; that current contract evidence supersedes discovery-time absence notes, without claiming Console integration. Next substantive MI work remains #12, not #15 production ingestion before proof/rights gate. No functional task selected or started. ## Package Metadata Disposition `pyproject.toml:8` retains the pre-existing bootstrap summary. Owner-approved no-edit alternative is explicitly recorded in #18 comment14425: keep this reviewed documentation-only scope and correct installed/package metadata consistently under existing #18 acceptance or a separately owner-selected metadata-only delivery, with proper package validation/fresh review. It is acknowledged stale, not presented as true current product status. No packaging edit or wheel build is claimed here. ## Validation and Review Ledger Initial3925e59 native COMMENT → round1 normal4381d24 → fresh native APPROVE at4381d24. A further fresh read-only canonical verification at unchanged4381d24 also returned APPROVE. Owner then selected terminology correction019082e; remediation budget is now 2/3, not reset. All older head-specific approvals are historical; a fresh review of current019082e is required and pending at this description update. Executed: `UV_OFFLINE=1 make check` PASS37 on corrected tree; locked sync, Ruff lint/format, basedpyright zero diagnostics, 35 R2 + two bootstrap tests, staged/unstaged whitespace. Full committed base-range whitespace and unchanged src/tests/Makefile/packaging/lock/native workflow checks PASS. Read-only scratch docs/registry checker PASS six ASCII docs/218 references/G01–G13 and actual consumer-link regressions. Exact/variant sweeps repeated successfully on committed019082e; whole-base semantic diff inspected. Forgejo reported no workflow runs; no CI success or live integration claimed. Packaging unchanged, isolated wheel/build not rerun. Source bytes/digest and sibling implementation/deployment not independently verified. Native verdict and any formal Forgejo review remain distinct; no branch-protection requirement inferred. Documentation readiness is not product GO, READY_FOR_LIVE_TASK, merge or completion of functional gaps.
kilo commented 2026-10-04 23:03:00 +00:00
Author
Member
Copy link

READY_TO_MERGE for this documentation PR only. Final fresh foreground native whole-PR/backlog review APPROVE with empty findings at HEAD 4381d242f072a01b7aa6fae6c1114c1a42abc8b1, base/merge base fb7299810fdc4612d4e0559465faef571662c6ef. Parent final canonical Git/MCP exact refs, open/unmerged develop target and clean checkout verified.

Review ledger: initial 3925e59877d5a3d7d9bda3161796790d470e388e → COMMENT, one P2 incomplete counterpart discovery plus independently unverifiable sibling-source assertions; one normal scoped remediation commit 4381d24; final 4381d242f072a01b7aa6fae6c1114c1a42abc8b1 → APPROVE. Both reviews newly spawned native pr-reviewer foreground contexts; no resumed reviewer, self-review substitute, relay or permissions bypass. Remediation used 1/3 rounds; no new temporal defect or scope expansion.

Final reviewer independently executed UV_OFFLINE=1 make check PASS37, basedpyright zero diagnostics, Ruff/locked sync/staged/unstaged whitespace; full frozen-range whitespace and unchanged product/tests/packaging/native workflow checks PASS. Parent final read-only doc/registry validation PASS6 ASCII docs/218 link-reference targets including consumer-link regressions. Review included whole six-file delta, G01–G13, MI #12–#19 bodies/comments and actual producer–consumer acceptance. No CI workflow runs found; build/isolated wheel unchanged/not rerun.

This comment records the substantive native verdict, NOT a formal Forgejo APPROVED review: platform reviews list is empty. No branch-protection requirement inferred. Full original source bytes/digest unavailable; no current source-data rights, live producer–consumer integration, deployed service or inference verified. Console has bootstrap context but no dedicated MI state/event consumer identified; MI #16 records owner/expected contract. These are explicit functional/source limits, not documentation merge blockers. #11 and all functional tasks remain open; human owner merge only. No product implementation/schema/test/dependency changes, secrets/effects/product inference/live task, merge/main/release/deploy.

READY_TO_MERGE for this documentation PR only. Final fresh foreground native whole-PR/backlog review APPROVE with empty findings at HEAD `4381d242f072a01b7aa6fae6c1114c1a42abc8b1`, base/merge base `fb7299810fdc4612d4e0559465faef571662c6ef`. Parent final canonical Git/MCP exact refs, open/unmerged develop target and clean checkout verified. Review ledger: initial `3925e59877d5a3d7d9bda3161796790d470e388e` → COMMENT, one P2 incomplete counterpart discovery plus independently unverifiable sibling-source assertions; one normal scoped remediation commit `4381d24`; final `4381d242f072a01b7aa6fae6c1114c1a42abc8b1` → APPROVE. Both reviews newly spawned native `pr-reviewer` foreground contexts; no resumed reviewer, self-review substitute, relay or permissions bypass. Remediation used 1/3 rounds; no new temporal defect or scope expansion. Final reviewer independently executed `UV_OFFLINE=1 make check` PASS37, basedpyright zero diagnostics, Ruff/locked sync/staged/unstaged whitespace; full frozen-range whitespace and unchanged product/tests/packaging/native workflow checks PASS. Parent final read-only doc/registry validation PASS6 ASCII docs/218 link-reference targets including consumer-link regressions. Review included whole six-file delta, G01–G13, MI #12–#19 bodies/comments and actual producer–consumer acceptance. No CI workflow runs found; build/isolated wheel unchanged/not rerun. This comment records the substantive native verdict, NOT a formal Forgejo APPROVED review: platform reviews list is empty. No branch-protection requirement inferred. Full original source bytes/digest unavailable; no current source-data rights, live producer–consumer integration, deployed service or inference verified. Console has bootstrap context but no dedicated MI state/event consumer identified; MI #16 records owner/expected contract. These are explicit functional/source limits, not documentation merge blockers. #11 and all functional tasks remain open; human owner merge only. No product implementation/schema/test/dependency changes, secrets/effects/product inference/live task, merge/main/release/deploy.
kilo commented 2026-10-04 23:58:32 +00:00
Author
Member
Copy link

Final Exact-HEAD Receipt

READY_TO_MERGE for the documentation PR only. Fresh foreground native pr-reviewer task ses_ef6ae46a0ffeoy1E4Adt14J1ko returned the direct frozen JSON verdict:

{
  "reviewed_head": "019082e8e42ede3a9173a4622a055390c92e0fa0",
  "reviewed_base": "fb7299810fdc4612d4e0559465faef571662c6ef",
  "verdict": "APPROVE",
  "findings": []
}

The whole six-file delta, current #11 acceptance, G01–G13 matrix, #12–#19 bodies/comments and relevant counterpart contracts were reviewed, not only the last correction. Native final make check PASS37, Ruff/format/locked sync/strict basedpyright zero diagnostics/whitespace; source/tests/packaging/lock/Makefile/native workflow unchanged. Final parent canonical verification at 2026-10-04T23:56:41Z confirmed open/unmerged PR20 targeting develop, exact matching Git/MCP refs, same merge base and clean checkout. Read-only GitHub mirror refs also match both canonical SHAs. Branch is3ahead/0behind, with three ordinary Adrian-authored commits. No later HEAD/base change invalidates this verdict as of that receipt.

Terminology and Mutable-State Receipt

Exact mandatory tracked-tree sweep and case/format/encoded/Unicode plus broad local sweep returned zero matches at final cleanHEAD. Two unnecessary active explanations were removed: ARCHITECTURE.md and issue11 body; ownership was not substituted. No Kernel/Scarcity Router compatibility alias, new component/API or terminology migration was introduced. Historical Git objects/closed records were not rewritten.
Fresh canonical audit covered all13openissue bodies,3openPR bodies and57existingcomments, with zero exact/normalized variants; no advertised record/comment omitted. This audit included old open STOP_REVISE records. #11 corrected body and comment14513 were read back; #12–#19 retain measurable criteria, non-goals, adversarial cases, textual prerequisites and owner decision gates. Native dependency/dependent edges for11–19 are empty, so the graph is not claimed as enforced. The two terminal receipt comments are added without repeating invalid architecture terminology.

Scope and Remaining Work

Remediation used2/3 rounds; no reset, amend, squash or force-push. Formal Forgejo reviews remain empty: this records a native result, not a platform APPROVED review or assumed protection compliance. CI reports no workflow runs; no CI/live acceptance credit.
Original source bytes/digest remain unavailable; sibling code/deployment and real-source rights/value are not independently proved. Current Console planning counterparts are recorded in16comment14308, superseding historical lookup absence without claiming delivery. Stale pyproject summary is explicitly dispositioned in18comment14425 under package/installed-metadata acceptance; no packaging edit/build or functional task started.
Next substantive MI step after owner integration remains12real-source A/B/C value and rights proof, not15production acquisition before accepted proof/contracts. Issue11 and all functional children remain open. No product/schema/test/dependency/permissions/secrets/service/cost-policy change, product inference/live task, merge/main/release/deploy. Full refreshed reviewer report is supplied separately with files, canonical task receipts, G01–G13, urgent product gaps, metadata disposition, checks and exact updated surfaces.

## Final Exact-HEAD Receipt READY_TO_MERGE for the documentation PR only. Fresh foreground native pr-reviewer task `ses_ef6ae46a0ffeoy1E4Adt14J1ko` returned the direct frozen JSON verdict: ```json { "reviewed_head": "019082e8e42ede3a9173a4622a055390c92e0fa0", "reviewed_base": "fb7299810fdc4612d4e0559465faef571662c6ef", "verdict": "APPROVE", "findings": [] } ``` The whole six-file delta, current #11 acceptance, G01–G13 matrix, #12–#19 bodies/comments and relevant counterpart contracts were reviewed, not only the last correction. Native final make check PASS37, Ruff/format/locked sync/strict basedpyright zero diagnostics/whitespace; source/tests/packaging/lock/Makefile/native workflow unchanged. Final parent canonical verification at 2026-10-04T23:56:41Z confirmed open/unmerged PR20 targeting develop, exact matching Git/MCP refs, same merge base and clean checkout. Read-only GitHub mirror refs also match both canonical SHAs. Branch is3ahead/0behind, with three ordinary Adrian-authored commits. No later HEAD/base change invalidates this verdict as of that receipt. ## Terminology and Mutable-State Receipt Exact mandatory tracked-tree sweep and case/format/encoded/Unicode plus broad local sweep returned zero matches at final cleanHEAD. Two unnecessary active explanations were removed: ARCHITECTURE.md and issue11 body; ownership was not substituted. No Kernel/Scarcity Router compatibility alias, new component/API or terminology migration was introduced. Historical Git objects/closed records were not rewritten. Fresh canonical audit covered all13openissue bodies,3openPR bodies and57existingcomments, with zero exact/normalized variants; no advertised record/comment omitted. This audit included old open STOP_REVISE records. #11 corrected body and comment14513 were read back; #12–#19 retain measurable criteria, non-goals, adversarial cases, textual prerequisites and owner decision gates. Native dependency/dependent edges for11–19 are empty, so the graph is not claimed as enforced. The two terminal receipt comments are added without repeating invalid architecture terminology. ## Scope and Remaining Work Remediation used2/3 rounds; no reset, amend, squash or force-push. Formal Forgejo reviews remain empty: this records a native result, not a platform APPROVED review or assumed protection compliance. CI reports no workflow runs; no CI/live acceptance credit. Original source bytes/digest remain unavailable; sibling code/deployment and real-source rights/value are not independently proved. Current Console planning counterparts are recorded in16comment14308, superseding historical lookup absence without claiming delivery. Stale pyproject summary is explicitly dispositioned in18comment14425 under package/installed-metadata acceptance; no packaging edit/build or functional task started. Next substantive MI step after owner integration remains12real-source A/B/C value and rights proof, not15production acquisition before accepted proof/contracts. Issue11 and all functional children remain open. No product/schema/test/dependency/permissions/secrets/service/cost-policy change, product inference/live task, merge/main/release/deploy. Full refreshed reviewer report is supplied separately with files, canonical task receipts, G01–G13, urgent product gaps, metadata disposition, checks and exact updated surfaces.
adrian.tkacz deleted branch issue-11-shared-architecture 2026-10-05 07:07:56 +00:00
Sign in to join this conversation.
Reviewers
No reviewers
adrian.tkacz
Labels
Clear labels   
bug
Something is not working

  
duplicate
This issue or pull request already exists

  
enhancement
New feature

  
help wanted
Need some help

  
invalid
Something is wrong

  
question
More information is needed

  
wontfix
This won't be fixed

No labels
bug
duplicate
enhancement
help wanted
invalid
question
wontfix
Milestone
Clear milestone
No items
No milestone
Projects
Clear projects
No items
No project
Assignees
Clear assignees
No assignees
2 participants
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference
Creatidy/model-intelligence!20
No description provided.