SUPERSEDED by #216: retire obsolete reviewer delivery (#205)

kilo commented

2026-10-11 00:12:29 +00:00

Member

Refs #205. SUPERSEDED by integrated PR #216 / D-078. No merge, new approval or review-budget reset. Adrian's direct 2026-10-24 mandate explicitly permits retirement when no necessary original-scope implementation remains.

Exact Zero Delta

Final append-only retirement HEAD 94dd82393fa2df1483f5b8b6bc7b0dc61b994b7d; develop b2b35bce6678ebc4e393e8c5d78f8c1044f4b119. HEAD tree, develop tree and conflict-free predicted merge tree are exactly 8529ea5bf1ee891a5e5c6d7f11175449609417fd; git diff --exit-code origin/develop HEAD passes. Do not merge an empty/redundant PR. Prior commits/source/findings/owner decisions remain available; no published history is rewritten or branch deleted.

Functional Coverage And Retirement

PR216 provides fresh independent native conversations, primary-selectable read-only reviewer, exact frozen Git/source access, supported native invocation and automatic final-result retrieval, bounded persistent review history, secret-safe recovery and operator-facing gates. These paths were actually exercised in PR216 ordinary review#9 and remain byte-identical here. Model identity/override honesty and manual official Codex security handling remain governed by accepted baseline policy plus the current model-agnostic owner mandate; no private/published model-strength assumption is introduced.

Retired: never-integrated subprocess launch/capture/claim/receipt helper, its synthetic fixture/tests/type include, obsolete standalone profile and conflicting workflow/model-policy changes. The helper had no installed product or native-session caller and required its own launch/exit/turn records; it was not a native Kilo recovery adapter. Existing optional offline reviewer_packet validators and official CLI/auth/recovery/product paths remain untouched.

The initially retained18-line fake Codex pipe-writer fixture fix was reassessed as optional unrelated test maintenance, not still-required #205 functionality after its associated capture harness was removed. It remains preserved at 8af0453 and earlier history, not represented as accepted product functionality or revived through excluded #166. Current baseline CLI behavior is retained; no accepted runtime functionality is removed.

Validation And Historical Gates

Exact baseline tree already passed PR216 full gate2855/17skips and independent review#9; canonical merge ancestry/tree was verified. Reconciliation candidate before final zero-delta retirement passed full gate2856/17skips, standalone type/package checks. Final exact-baseline retirement rechecked187 acquisition/workflow/reviewer-packet tests, basedpyright0, whitespace and byte/tree equality. No model inference or real credentials in tests.

Historical #1-21 outcomes and conditional #22 restrictions remain unchanged. No new formal review, #23/reset/transfer, Daybreak invocation, integration approval or implementation merge is claimed. Retirement is the owner's explicit supersession decision, not bypass of an unmet gate for merging implementation.

Refs #205. **SUPERSEDED by integrated PR #216 / D-078. No merge, new approval or review-budget reset.** Adrian's direct 2026-10-24 mandate explicitly permits retirement when no necessary original-scope implementation remains. ## Exact Zero Delta Final append-only retirement HEAD `94dd82393fa2df1483f5b8b6bc7b0dc61b994b7d`; develop `b2b35bce6678ebc4e393e8c5d78f8c1044f4b119`. HEAD tree, develop tree and conflict-free predicted merge tree are exactly `8529ea5bf1ee891a5e5c6d7f11175449609417fd`; `git diff --exit-code origin/develop HEAD` passes. Do not merge an empty/redundant PR. Prior commits/source/findings/owner decisions remain available; no published history is rewritten or branch deleted. ## Functional Coverage And Retirement PR216 provides fresh independent native conversations, primary-selectable read-only reviewer, exact frozen Git/source access, supported native invocation and automatic final-result retrieval, bounded persistent review history, secret-safe recovery and operator-facing gates. These paths were actually exercised in PR216 ordinary review#9 and remain byte-identical here. Model identity/override honesty and manual official Codex security handling remain governed by accepted baseline policy plus the current model-agnostic owner mandate; no private/published model-strength assumption is introduced. Retired: never-integrated subprocess launch/capture/claim/receipt helper, its synthetic fixture/tests/type include, obsolete standalone profile and conflicting workflow/model-policy changes. The helper had no installed product or native-session caller and required its own launch/exit/turn records; it was not a native Kilo recovery adapter. Existing optional offline reviewer_packet validators and official CLI/auth/recovery/product paths remain untouched. The initially retained18-line fake Codex pipe-writer fixture fix was reassessed as optional unrelated test maintenance, not still-required #205 functionality after its associated capture harness was removed. It remains preserved at `8af0453` and earlier history, not represented as accepted product functionality or revived through excluded #166. Current baseline CLI behavior is retained; no accepted runtime functionality is removed. ## Validation And Historical Gates Exact baseline tree already passed PR216 full gate2855/17skips and independent review#9; canonical merge ancestry/tree was verified. Reconciliation candidate before final zero-delta retirement passed full gate2856/17skips, standalone type/package checks. Final exact-baseline retirement rechecked187 acquisition/workflow/reviewer-packet tests, basedpyright0, whitespace and byte/tree equality. No model inference or real credentials in tests. Historical #1-21 outcomes and conditional #22 restrictions remain unchanged. No new formal review, #23/reset/transfer, Daybreak invocation, integration approval or implementation merge is claimed. Retirement is the owner's explicit supersession decision, not bypass of an unmet gate for merging implementation.

kilo added 1 commit

2026-10-11 00:12:30 +00:00