Record D-083 backlog disposition: re-home excluded wontfix requirements (#228)

kilo commented

2026-10-27 21:41:30 +00:00

Member

Refs #228. Records the owner's 2026-10-27 backlog disposition (D-083) as one coherent governance delivery. Documentation only; no product code, public contract, label/state change on the six historical issues (#132/#139/#140/#141/#165/#166 remain open wontfix, history preserved), release/tag/deploy/signing/live-call authority.

Changes

docs/decisions.md: new D-083 — prospective correction recording the no-rationale 2026-10-05 labels as history, the full re-homing table (old issue → new owner → stage → retained invariant) and the dependency corrections.
docs/roadmap.md, docs/security.md, docs/release-engineering.md, docs/m10-acceptance.md, docs/control-surface.md, docs/architecture.md, docs/execution-surface.md: every current-facing reference to excluded-issue content now points to its active successor (#224 transport/TLS, #225 cancellation P1, #226 admin UX, #227 composed acceptance) or to #183's integrated producer-state scope. Historical decision text untouched.

Companion Forgejo state (already applied under the same 2026-10-27 authorization)

Registered #224/#225 (P1+bug)/#226/#227 and governance issue #228 with implementation-grade bodies and evidence.
#183/#186 body prerequisite corrections; native edges removed: #183→#140, #186→#139, #186→#141; added #227→#183, #227→#186. Read back in both directions: #183 deps = [#179 closed], #186 deps = [#185 closed], #227 deps = [#183, #186]; dependents of #183/#186 = [#227]. Cycle-free, no inverted prerequisites.
Factual disposition comments posted on all six historical issues.

Validation

uv sync --only-dev; make check 3057 tests OK / 16 runtime-probe skips (745.957s); uv run basedpyright 0/0/0; git diff --check clean. Synthetic environment only; no inference, publication or live operation.

Refs #228. Records the owner's 2026-10-27 backlog disposition (D-083) as one coherent governance delivery. Documentation only; no product code, public contract, label/state change on the six historical issues (#132/#139/#140/#141/#165/#166 remain open `wontfix`, history preserved), release/tag/deploy/signing/live-call authority. ## Changes - `docs/decisions.md`: new **D-083** — prospective correction recording the no-rationale 2026-10-05 labels as history, the full re-homing table (old issue → new owner → stage → retained invariant) and the dependency corrections. - `docs/roadmap.md`, `docs/security.md`, `docs/release-engineering.md`, `docs/m10-acceptance.md`, `docs/control-surface.md`, `docs/architecture.md`, `docs/execution-surface.md`: every current-facing reference to excluded-issue content now points to its active successor (#224 transport/TLS, #225 cancellation P1, #226 admin UX, #227 composed acceptance) or to #183's integrated producer-state scope. Historical decision text untouched. ## Companion Forgejo state (already applied under the same 2026-10-27 authorization) - Registered #224/#225 (P1+bug)/#226/#227 and governance issue #228 with implementation-grade bodies and evidence. - #183/#186 body prerequisite corrections; native edges removed: #183→#140, #186→#139, #186→#141; added #227→#183, #227→#186. Read back in both directions: #183 deps = [#179 closed], #186 deps = [#185 closed], #227 deps = [#183, #186]; dependents of #183/#186 = [#227]. Cycle-free, no inverted prerequisites. - Factual disposition comments posted on all six historical issues. ## Validation `uv sync --only-dev`; `make check` 3057 tests OK / 16 runtime-probe skips (745.957s); `uv run basedpyright` 0/0/0; `git diff --check` clean. Synthetic environment only; no inference, publication or live operation.

kilo added 1 commit

2026-10-27 21:41:30 +00:00

Record D-083 backlog disposition and re-home excluded requirements (#228 )

ci / check (pull_request) Failing after 5s

Details

3fc37bb7ee

kilo commented

2026-10-27 21:41:43 +00:00

Author

Member

Review ordinal record: #1 (initial independent review) dispatched to a fresh native read-only Kilo reviewer session (pr-reviewer role) over frozen HEAD 3fc37bb7ee8b6d259ad30b1f373013392e745e0c, base/merge-base 4a182affa4775a4a38b47860ad7622a099c56c4a. Default finite bound 10 whole-PR reviews for this delivery. Outcome will be recorded here. Source frozen during review; no pushes/edits.

Review ordinal record: **#1** (initial independent review) dispatched to a fresh native read-only Kilo reviewer session (pr-reviewer role) over frozen HEAD `3fc37bb7ee8b6d259ad30b1f373013392e745e0c`, base/merge-base `4a182affa4775a4a38b47860ad7622a099c56c4a`. Default finite bound 10 whole-PR reviews for this delivery. Outcome will be recorded here. Source frozen during review; no pushes/edits.

kilo commented

2026-10-28 11:07:10 +00:00

Author

Member

Preserved reviewer dispatch payload (native session creation is currently not processing agent-initiated requests; if a reviewer session is started from the Agent Manager UI, begin with exactly this task):

Perform an independent, read-only whole-PR review of BioMedical-IT/scarcity-router PR #229. Exact refs: HEAD 3fc37bb7ee8b6d259ad30b1f373013392e745e0c (branch issue-228-backlog-disposition); base = merge-base = develop 4a182affa4775a4a38b47860ad7622a099c56c4a. Review the complete diff (git show 3fc37bb…, git diff 4a182af…3fc37bb…); confirm the pushed tip via git ls-remote …refs/heads/issue-228-backlog-disposition. 8 files, documentation only.

Acceptance (issue #228): D-083 in docs/decisions.md records the 2026-10-27 owner backlog disposition with the re-homing table (old issue → new owner → stage → retained invariant) for excluded wontfix #132/#139/#140/#141/#165/#166, prospective framing only, historical text untouched; every current-facing doc reference to excluded-issue content now points to active owners #224/#225/#226/#227/#183 with no excluded issue presented as a blocking prerequisite (outside explicit successor-of/historical phrasing); no product code, public contract, security-posture or historical-issue label/state changes. Verify via read-only Forgejo getters: successor scopes match; #225 labeled P1+bug; the six historical issues open with exact wontfix; native dependencies #183→[#179], #186→[#185], #227→[#183,#186], cycle-free. Check factual accuracy, internal consistency, table integrity, no security-invariant weakening, no secrets. Full file contents at the reviewed commit via git show 3fc37bb:<path>.

The implementer's full gate was green (make check 3057 OK / 16 skips; basedpyright 0/0/0); targeted verification preferred. Deliver: verdict exactly APPROVE / CHANGES_REQUESTED / COMMENT; findings list; limitations; a UX impact: line; the frozen refs actually reviewed. Modify nothing; push nothing; read-only Forgejo getters only.

Preserved reviewer dispatch payload (native session creation is currently not processing agent-initiated requests; if a reviewer session is started from the Agent Manager UI, begin with exactly this task): > Perform an independent, read-only whole-PR review of BioMedical-IT/scarcity-router PR #229. Exact refs: HEAD `3fc37bb7ee8b6d259ad30b1f373013392e745e0c` (branch `issue-228-backlog-disposition`); base = merge-base = develop `4a182affa4775a4a38b47860ad7622a099c56c4a`. Review the complete diff (`git show 3fc37bb…`, `git diff 4a182af…3fc37bb…`); confirm the pushed tip via `git ls-remote …refs/heads/issue-228-backlog-disposition`. 8 files, documentation only. > > Acceptance (issue #228): D-083 in `docs/decisions.md` records the 2026-10-27 owner backlog disposition with the re-homing table (old issue → new owner → stage → retained invariant) for excluded `wontfix` #132/#139/#140/#141/#165/#166, prospective framing only, historical text untouched; every current-facing doc reference to excluded-issue content now points to active owners #224/#225/#226/#227/#183 with no excluded issue presented as a blocking prerequisite (outside explicit successor-of/historical phrasing); no product code, public contract, security-posture or historical-issue label/state changes. Verify via read-only Forgejo getters: successor scopes match; #225 labeled P1+bug; the six historical issues open with exact `wontfix`; native dependencies #183→[#179], #186→[#185], #227→[#183,#186], cycle-free. Check factual accuracy, internal consistency, table integrity, no security-invariant weakening, no secrets. Full file contents at the reviewed commit via `git show 3fc37bb:<path>`. > > The implementer's full gate was green (make check 3057 OK / 16 skips; basedpyright 0/0/0); targeted verification preferred. Deliver: verdict exactly APPROVE / CHANGES_REQUESTED / COMMENT; findings list; limitations; a `UX impact:` line; the frozen refs actually reviewed. Modify nothing; push nothing; read-only Forgejo getters only.

kilo referenced this pull request

2026-10-28 11:07:28 +00:00

P1: Complete cancellation propagation outside the established stream path (#225) #230

kilo commented

2026-10-28 11:19:03 +00:00

Author

Member

Recovery/ordinal correction, 2026-10-28: actual Agent Manager overview contains only orchestrator ses_e80ff8c5fffe2wpNFNzV06FcLS; no independent reviewer session or verdict exists. Four previously accepted asynchronous start requests (am-1793137344526-m9w5rz, am-1793137665172-01up3u, am-1793141686320-pouqya, am-1793185449625-v21qc2) did not materialize. Preserve them conservatively as failed creation attempts #1–4 of the default maximum10; validation-rejected tool inputs/list operations did not launch reviews. Diagnosis: previous inputs passed literal string "null" (including worktreeID), not JSON null; absence of sessions was not evidence that the extension itself was broken. Owner has now reloaded the window. Imminent corrected native local-session dispatch is ordinal #5/10, explicitly GLM-5.3 via zai-coding-plan, pr-reviewer read-only role, existing frozen checkout HEAD 3fc37bb7ee, base/merge-base 4a182affa4. No implementation restart, worktree or infrastructure creation.

Recovery/ordinal correction, 2026-10-28: actual Agent Manager overview contains only orchestrator ses_e80ff8c5fffe2wpNFNzV06FcLS; no independent reviewer session or verdict exists. Four previously accepted asynchronous start requests (am-1793137344526-m9w5rz, am-1793137665172-01up3u, am-1793141686320-pouqya, am-1793185449625-v21qc2) did not materialize. Preserve them conservatively as failed creation attempts #1–4 of the default maximum10; validation-rejected tool inputs/list operations did not launch reviews. Diagnosis: previous inputs passed literal string "null" (including worktreeID), not JSON null; absence of sessions was not evidence that the extension itself was broken. Owner has now reloaded the window. Imminent corrected native local-session dispatch is ordinal #5/10, explicitly GLM-5.3 via zai-coding-plan, pr-reviewer read-only role, existing frozen checkout HEAD 3fc37bb7ee8b6d259ad30b1f373013392e745e0c, base/merge-base 4a182affa4775a4a38b47860ad7622a099c56c4a. No implementation restart, worktree or infrastructure creation.

kilo commented

2026-10-28 11:20:00 +00:00

Author

Member

Corrected native dispatch succeeded: Agent Manager overview verifies actual fresh local reviewer session ses_e7dc3852cffeKCSo42D201Kbcr (busy), request am-1793186364072-gbm3m3, resolved GLM-5.3 / zai-coding-plan, pr-reviewer read-only role, ordinal5/10, frozen HEAD3fc37bb7ee8b6d259ad30b1f373013392e745e0c / base=merge-base4a182affa4775a4a38b47860ad7622a099c56c4a. No separate worktree, manual relay or hidden review mechanism. Prior extension-broken diagnosis was unsupported; corrected JSON null parameters restored session creation.

kilo commented

2026-10-28 11:25:38 +00:00

Author

Member

Ordinal5/10 final result retrieved directly from native independent session ses_e7dc3852cffeKCSo42D201Kbcr, GLM-5.3/zai-coding-plan, read-only pr-reviewer role: APPROVE, findings=[], UX impact:none, exact reviewed HEAD3fc37bb7ee8b6d259ad30b1f373013392e745e0c/base=merge-base4a182affa4775a4a38b47860ad7622a099c56c4a. Same-invocation schema clarification distinguished an expressly informational out-of-scope worker_service.py cross-reference from actual PR findings; no source changes or second whole-PR review. Reviewer verified all eight changed doc files, successor/historical issues and bidirectional native graph. No material scope/security limitation. Reviewer did not rerun previously successful full gate; primary independently verified clean checkout and exact fresh refs (reviewer status command was denied by its role). Preserved gate:3057 tests OK/16 skips,basedpyright0/0/0,whitespace clean. Source unchanged since that gate. Proceeding under explicit owner integration/loop authority, no release/deploy.

kilo merged commit 2c40e0e1fb into develop

2026-10-28 11:25:46 +00:00

kilo referenced this pull request from a commit

2026-10-28 11:25:47 +00:00

Merge pull request #229: D-083 backlog reconciliation

Rows
Columns

Record D-083 backlog disposition: re-home excluded wontfix requirements (#228) #229

Changes

Companion Forgejo state (already applied under the same 2026-10-27 authorization)

Validation