Self-remediate technical workflow blockers before owner escalation (#190) #192

Merged

kilo merged 2 commits from issue-190-workflow-self-remediation into develop

2026-10-05 14:12:49 +00:00

kilo commented

2026-10-05 13:52:21 +00:00

Member

Change

Refs #190. Generic shared bounded technical-recovery contract applied consistently to loop, implementation, review/remediation, reviewer instructions and shared policy. Distinguish technical obstacles, owner decisions, review defects, infrastructure failure and unresolved judgment. Permit minimum-sufficient sanitized/ephemeral execution paths, independent pinned public-source verification and authorized native reviewer failover without broadening permissions.

D-070 supersedes only conflicting blanket checkout/retry constraints. Preserve ten review ordinals, exact-HEAD/base independent review, restricted gates, future validation and existing merge/product/security authority. Offline text consistency guards do not claim live failover/isolation proof. No product/runtime code or reviewer permission-frontmatter changes.

Authority

Owner explicitly authorized isolated worktree from develop, PR, independent review and gated automatic merge for this delivery. Ongoing task checkout untouched.

Validation

Before owner stopped testing: 15 focused contract tests passed; full verbose suite passed 2,689 tests (17 existing skips); basedpyright reported 0 errors/warnings/notes. A later make-check invocation hit an unchanged pipe fixture race; serialized run was owner-aborted. At 13:50Z owner instructed: "Stop testing, this is docs only change". No tests/typechecks after that instruction; issue acceptance records this explicit one-delivery revision. Final remediation inspected text-only. Diff/staged whitespace checks passed. No enforced server-check bypass.

Independent Review

Persistent ordinals: 1 COMMENT (external-directory isolation), 2 COMMENT (loaded reviewer normal-checkout constraint), 3 REQUEST_CHANGES (terminal classification inconsistency), 4 APPROVE with empty findings. Changed recovery strategies: move delivery worktree inside workspace, then prepare normal canonical evidence clone. No permission widening or self-review. P2 text finding fixed in ordinary remediation commit.

Fresh whole-PR review 4 approved exact HEAD fd874477fc against base/merge-base 6c337a400b. Review was text/Git only per owner, with UX/security/authority assessed; no live execution proof claimed. Final canonical currentness matched these objects and both delivery/review checkouts were clean.

## Change Refs #190. Generic shared bounded technical-recovery contract applied consistently to loop, implementation, review/remediation, reviewer instructions and shared policy. Distinguish technical obstacles, owner decisions, review defects, infrastructure failure and unresolved judgment. Permit minimum-sufficient sanitized/ephemeral execution paths, independent pinned public-source verification and authorized native reviewer failover without broadening permissions. D-070 supersedes only conflicting blanket checkout/retry constraints. Preserve ten review ordinals, exact-HEAD/base independent review, restricted gates, future validation and existing merge/product/security authority. Offline text consistency guards do not claim live failover/isolation proof. No product/runtime code or reviewer permission-frontmatter changes. ## Authority Owner explicitly authorized isolated worktree from develop, PR, independent review and gated automatic merge for this delivery. Ongoing task checkout untouched. ## Validation Before owner stopped testing: 15 focused contract tests passed; full verbose suite passed 2,689 tests (17 existing skips); basedpyright reported 0 errors/warnings/notes. A later make-check invocation hit an unchanged pipe fixture race; serialized run was owner-aborted. At 13:50Z owner instructed: "Stop testing, this is docs only change". No tests/typechecks after that instruction; issue acceptance records this explicit one-delivery revision. Final remediation inspected text-only. Diff/staged whitespace checks passed. No enforced server-check bypass. ## Independent Review Persistent ordinals: 1 COMMENT (external-directory isolation), 2 COMMENT (loaded reviewer normal-checkout constraint), 3 REQUEST_CHANGES (terminal classification inconsistency), 4 APPROVE with empty findings. Changed recovery strategies: move delivery worktree inside workspace, then prepare normal canonical evidence clone. No permission widening or self-review. P2 text finding fixed in ordinary remediation commit. Fresh whole-PR review 4 approved exact HEAD fd874477fcd348464eb86290340eec8f48f54f35 against base/merge-base 6c337a400b4cdc28ded543d2ae8ccf3749d79cb7. Review was text/Git only per owner, with UX/security/authority assessed; no live execution proof claimed. Final canonical currentness matched these objects and both delivery/review checkouts were clean.

kilo added 1 commit

2026-10-05 13:52:21 +00:00