Define conversational independence for native reviews #41

Merged

kilo merged 1 commit from docs/conversational-review-policy into develop

2026-10-23 23:21:01 +00:00

kilo commented

2026-10-23 23:18:08 +00:00

Member

Authority and Scope

Explicit repository-owner directive: establish the permanent repository-local conversational-independence policy, followed by owner acceptance and instruction to commit and merge these changes into develop. This is a narrow documentation/configuration delivery, not a selected functional issue or autonomous queue invocation. No issue registration or closure is requested.

Acceptance

Root AGENTS.md is authoritative: independent reviewer means a fresh separate conversation with no implementation context; shared checkout, tools and prepared execution environment are permitted.
Reconcile only conflicting dependent instructions; use native reviewer tasks and direct automatic result handoff without owner-mediated prompt transfer.
Separate execution requires concrete technical necessity, not independence alone.
Preserve read-only permissions, exact frozen source and source stability, finite review ceilings/history, mandatory security/acceptance gates, and integration authority.
No product code, runtime dependencies, agent-platform internals, launchers, services or unrelated architecture changes.

Change

Six instruction files: AGENTS.md, .kilo/agents/pr-reviewer.md, .kilo/command/loop.md, .kilo/command/review-pr.md, .kilo/rules/validation.md, .kilo/rules/50-technical-remediation.md. Clarifies ambiguous isolation terminology and removes a stale command-level fixed-model reference in favor of the existing agent-owned inherited/owner-overridden binding. Reviewer permissions are unchanged.

Frozen Candidate

Base: 3a24170185
Head: ba0fcb30e0
Normal checkout; clean committed candidate; effective Git author/committer Adrian Tkacz adrian.tkacz@creatidy.com.

Executed Validation

Exact committed candidate passed make check in an offline allowlisted child environment with synthetic HOME/temp/cache settings: locked sync, Ruff lint/format, basedpyright (0 errors/warnings), 178 unittest tests, staged/unstaged whitespace checks. Complete base delta is limited to the six instruction files. Kilo configuration validation passed during editing.

Fresh native independent exact-PR review/currentness checks precede the owner-authorized supported Forgejo merge. No main/release/deploy authority.

## Authority and Scope Explicit repository-owner directive: establish the permanent repository-local conversational-independence policy, followed by owner acceptance and instruction to commit and merge these changes into develop. This is a narrow documentation/configuration delivery, not a selected functional issue or autonomous queue invocation. No issue registration or closure is requested. ## Acceptance - Root AGENTS.md is authoritative: independent reviewer means a fresh separate conversation with no implementation context; shared checkout, tools and prepared execution environment are permitted. - Reconcile only conflicting dependent instructions; use native reviewer tasks and direct automatic result handoff without owner-mediated prompt transfer. - Separate execution requires concrete technical necessity, not independence alone. - Preserve read-only permissions, exact frozen source and source stability, finite review ceilings/history, mandatory security/acceptance gates, and integration authority. - No product code, runtime dependencies, agent-platform internals, launchers, services or unrelated architecture changes. ## Change Six instruction files: AGENTS.md, .kilo/agents/pr-reviewer.md, .kilo/command/loop.md, .kilo/command/review-pr.md, .kilo/rules/validation.md, .kilo/rules/50-technical-remediation.md. Clarifies ambiguous isolation terminology and removes a stale command-level fixed-model reference in favor of the existing agent-owned inherited/owner-overridden binding. Reviewer permissions are unchanged. ## Frozen Candidate Base: 3a241701851eeaed2fbc0cd4b8a1e9417bb0f02d Head: ba0fcb30e07d10ba652aa639d813962e84dee242 Normal checkout; clean committed candidate; effective Git author/committer Adrian Tkacz <adrian.tkacz@creatidy.com>. ## Executed Validation Exact committed candidate passed make check in an offline allowlisted child environment with synthetic HOME/temp/cache settings: locked sync, Ruff lint/format, basedpyright (0 errors/warnings), 178 unittest tests, staged/unstaged whitespace checks. Complete base delta is limited to the six instruction files. Kilo configuration validation passed during editing. Fresh native independent exact-PR review/currentness checks precede the owner-authorized supported Forgejo merge. No main/release/deploy authority.

kilo added 1 commit

2026-10-23 23:18:08 +00:00