Migrate Console commands to the Model Intelligence loop workflow #17
No reviewers
Labels
No labels
No milestone
No project
No assignees
2 participants
Notifications
Due date
No due date set.
Dependencies
No dependencies set.
Reference
Creatidy/creatidy-console!17
Loading…
Add table
Add a link
Reference in a new issue
No description provided.
Delete branch "issue-16-loop-workflow"
Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?
Refs #16.
Reviewed Subject
READY_FOR_OWNER_MERGE, source migration only. PR and issue remain open/unmerged; this invocation does not authorize merging or invoking the proposed
/loop.cbdc23103a.38121045b6.issue-16-loop-workflow, one existing normal checkout.Authoritative Reference and Inventory
Actual current local
~/workspace/model-intelligencewas read, not remembered text or an older template. Clean inspected HEAD 013cbb43e11d7f698d359db5a456d26d8075e34e. All four commands, reviewer, five rules, AGENTS and Python workflow contract test were inspected; all11 workflow/test Git blob fingerprints unchanged at parent recheck. Independent reviewer again read the actual clean local reference. No reference mutation; a concurrent branch-name change left input contents/HEAD unchanged.Before: no repository
.kilo/command/*files, no obsolete unique command functionality to retain.After: exactly
/implement-issue,/review-pr,/finish-pr,/loop. No duplicate or obsolete command system.Preserved Workflow
Explicit owner
/looponly, sole primary orchestrator, one normal checkout/one mutator, no worktrees/alternate checkout/stash-reset/second controller/service/daemon. Every cycle fetch all canonical open issues to exhaustion. ONLY exact case-insensitive invalid/wontfix/duplicate exclusions, then explicit prerequisites and unresolved decisions; explicit priority/required ordering/oldest created_at/ascending issue-number ties. Issues plan work, not open PRs. Pre-merge excluded delivery returns safely to clean develop and SELECT nonterminally, without merge/closure or exclusion-only stop status.Fresh isolated read-only foreground complete-PR
pr-reviewer, exact frozen HEAD/base/merge-base; no self/resumed review. Model/variant, deny-default isolation and six-field JSON contract retained. Excluded.task_progress.mdissue-delivery ledger reserves ordinal before dispatch; maximum10 whole-PR reviews including initial/COMMENT/invalidation/retry, counter survives finish/phase/task/model/session, no reset or review11. Missing recovery BLOCKED; changed HEAD/base invalidates approval. Bound/owner/infrastructure/remediation outcomes preserved.Only explicit
/loopcan use supported Forgejo PR merge into develop after current issue/PR/base/HEAD/approval/checkout/check/gate/label/authority checks. No direct develop push, force/auto-merge or alternative REST integration. Verify actual merge, mergecommit in develop, approved HEAD ancestry and integrated acceptance before completed closure, verify closed state, safely return same checkout and rebuild SELECT. Genuine STOP_AND_ASK terminates the entire invocation with evidence/alternatives; routine reversible scoped engineering is autonomous.No Scarcity Router model selection, execution, orchestration, telemetry or operation. No cross-repository mutation, speculative issues, main, release or deployment authority.
Files and Necessary Deviations
17 intended files:
.kilo/command/*.md,.kilo/agents/pr-reviewer.mdand five.kilo/rules/*.md.tests/test_workflow_contract.pyto existingtests/workflow-contract.test.mjs.Deviations are technical/product identity only:
make check, typecheck and Vitest reviewer allowlist replaces uv/Python checks. No Python runtime, dependency or weaker gate added.No loop-model or safety-semantic deviation. Reviewer/review-pr differ only by Console URL, offline validation, required formatting/heading and attribution; model/variant, result schema and deny rules are unchanged. License: upstream Apache-2.0 Copyright2026Creatidy; preserved in NOTICE. No product source, package/lock, scripts, CI or architecture redesign.
Local
.git/info/excludeadded.task_progress.mdbefore ledger creation; Git ignore verified. Ledger never tracked or added to .gitignore, and existing public-file gates respect this exclusion. Review ordinals/results persisted for this migration; no controller database introduced.Validation and Independent Review
npm test -- tests/workflow-contract.test.mjs: 11 passed.make check: PASS; Prettier,20 Markdown files zero lint issues, local AST links, current-public secretlint, strict TypeScript,16 tests across3 files and real temporary licensed static artifact+cleanup.npm_config_offline=true make check: PASS.Fresh native Task ses_ef49e49ddffeDMMhS4IyYKOCIF reviewed the complete17-file PR, actual current local reference, acceptance, isolation, selection, persistent ceiling, merge/completion, attribution and necessary adaptations. JSON verdict APPROVE, findings empty. Reviewer performed no mutations and deliberately did not read private operational notes or claim hosted CI/runtime enforcement.
Delivery used the currently valid pre-migration develop-policy native independent review, not candidate command authority. Conservative predeclared budget 1/3 review rounds,0/2 remediation cycles; ordinal reserved before dispatch. The proposed ten-review ceiling/merge exception did not authorize this unmerged migration. Source approval is not formal platform approval or branch-protection bypass.
Remaining Limitations
kiloexecutable is absent from current shell PATH; live config validation reports No context found for instance. Formatting validates syntax, not command/native-agent discovery, model resolution or runtime permission enforcement. Workspace reload/runtime availability may be required after integration; actual future missing agent/tool must BLOCKED, not self-review/fallback. Offline contracts do not execute/loop, merge/closure or attest infrastructure. These limitations are recorded in #16, not hidden as runtime success.No Scarcity Router used, no worktrees/alternate checkout, no external repository mutation, no live product task/inference/secrets/provider changes, no loop invocation/direct develop push/issue completion/merge/main/release/publication/deployment.
READY_FOR_OWNER_MERGE, reviewed source migration only; PR remains unmerged.
Fresh independent whole-PR native review under pre-migration develop policy: substantive APPROVE, no findings. Reviewer Task ses_ef49e49ddffeDMMhS4IyYKOCIF, fresh foreground isolated read-only context, no resumed reviewer or implementation self-review. Native existing review mechanism used; unmerged candidate command/agent/loop not used as authority.
Exact reviewed base:
cbdc23103a.Exact reviewed HEAD:
38121045b6.Complete17-file PR plus actual current local Model Intelligence command/rule/reviewer/test/license reference013cbb43e11d7f698d359db5a456d26d8075e34e inspected. Scope/selection/filter/order/premerge-exclusion/review-bound/authority/completion/isolation/reuse/attribution/Console adaptations assessed.
Executed npm_config_offline=true make check PASS:20Markdown files zero lint issues, Prettier/localASTlinks/currentpublicsecrets/strictTypeScript,16tests3files including11workflow cases, actual temporary licensed static artifact+cleanup. Whole-PR whitespace PASS. Exact canonical/local/PR/base/merge-base clean/current before and after. Reference checkout clean/unchanged; no cross-repository writes.
Limits: no runtime command/native-agent discovery, model resolution or permission enforcement exercised; no loop/merge/closure/producer operation/inference; no hosted CI check by reviewer or runner-containment proof; excluded operational ledger deliberately not read. Source/offline approval is not live loop authority or approval to merge.
Stored state COMMENT, not formal APPROVED (shared author/review MCP account kilo); this relays independent native approval, not platform identity fiction or branch-protection bypass. Migration budget1/3reviews,0/2remediation cycles; ordinal reserved before dispatch in locally excluded ledger. Proposed10review policy not borrowed to authorize this unmerged migration. No merge/release/deployment.