Record rejection of current operational intake and preserve reconsideration #33

Merged

kilo merged 2 commits from issue-17-sharing-decision into develop

2026-10-06 14:46:00 +00:00

kilo commented

2026-10-06 08:52:37 +00:00

Member

Refs #17

Completed Owner Decision

Adrian's explicit decision on 2026-10-06T14:23:48Z: REJECT current operational intake, canonical transcription15400. All rationale points and seven reconsideration criteria preserved in packet revision2/public status. No MI receiver/private collection/production sharing format/automatic calibration/centralized private-export ingestion. Not permanent prohibition, sharing permission, product GO, installed acceptance or waiver of #15/#16/#18/#19 gates.

Verified Delivery

Reviewed base/merge base a1d985e3635da30416aea898dccebd0017bfe49a; approved HEAD d54ef5d64c3d57e04c0c91111672620cd2ecaa3a.
Fresh whole-PR ordinal2/10 ses_eee57eac3ffeSuYUNU4OpxuL6Q: APPROVE/findings empty, all five acceptance criteria/owner directive/material source evidence verified. Initial ordinal1 COMMENT retained; no history/review-counter reset.
Actual supported normal merge 98b270e387571decceb9be7d177d122656de9fa3, exact reviewed parents and approved tree 56b19d3d75f8033c48db25de69baeac8f1ea6ac5; ancestry/tree independently observed. Integrated clean canonical develop make check PASS115, Ruff/format35, basedpyright0, offline locked sync and staged/unstaged whitespace. Completion15412; issue17 closed and freshly verified2026-10-06T14:47:44Z.

Five substantive files only: OPERATIONAL_SHARING_REVIEW.md, README.md, ARCHITECTURE.md, ROADMAP.md, tests/test_operational_sharing_review.py. No production src/dependency/lock/wire/collection, foreign mutation, private records, publishing/release/deploy or inference.

Preserved Limits

Ten policy examples are prospective requirements, not consent/redaction/recipient lifecycle enforcement. Owned mathematical/hash examples and current public-producer independence are not anonymity/GDPR/causal-quality/complete-cost guarantees. Exact source cuts remain Kernel9dfa20931a46931d1e97d1f0efddcf2692afb7a7/Router1dae1948f372e0f1739896655bb7db97d6b08460, RFC6973Jul2013 Informational and arxiv2107.07002v1 abstract only, citation/no-adoption bounds verified.

Future return requires named public problem, demonstrated improvement over public/reproducible/local alternatives, necessary fields, explicit producer-consumer/lifecycle, voluntary scoped consent where private, source/user rights/negative conformance and separate owner approval before separately selected implementation. No collection issue registered/selected. Full canonical queue refresh resumes normal loop selection with independent actual gates.

Refs #17 ## Completed Owner Decision Adrian's explicit decision on 2026-10-06T14:23:48Z: **REJECT current operational intake**, canonical transcription15400. All rationale points and seven reconsideration criteria preserved in packet revision2/public status. No MI receiver/private collection/production sharing format/automatic calibration/centralized private-export ingestion. Not permanent prohibition, sharing permission, product GO, installed acceptance or waiver of #15/#16/#18/#19 gates. ## Verified Delivery Reviewed base/merge base `a1d985e3635da30416aea898dccebd0017bfe49a`; approved HEAD `d54ef5d64c3d57e04c0c91111672620cd2ecaa3a`. Fresh whole-PR ordinal2/10 `ses_eee57eac3ffeSuYUNU4OpxuL6Q`: APPROVE/findings empty, all five acceptance criteria/owner directive/material source evidence verified. Initial ordinal1 COMMENT retained; no history/review-counter reset. Actual supported normal merge `98b270e387571decceb9be7d177d122656de9fa3`, exact reviewed parents and approved tree `56b19d3d75f8033c48db25de69baeac8f1ea6ac5`; ancestry/tree independently observed. Integrated clean canonical develop make check PASS115, Ruff/format35, basedpyright0, offline locked sync and staged/unstaged whitespace. Completion15412; issue17 closed and freshly verified2026-10-06T14:47:44Z. Five substantive files only: OPERATIONAL_SHARING_REVIEW.md, README.md, ARCHITECTURE.md, ROADMAP.md, tests/test_operational_sharing_review.py. No production src/dependency/lock/wire/collection, foreign mutation, private records, publishing/release/deploy or inference. ## Preserved Limits Ten policy examples are prospective requirements, not consent/redaction/recipient lifecycle enforcement. Owned mathematical/hash examples and current public-producer independence are not anonymity/GDPR/causal-quality/complete-cost guarantees. Exact source cuts remain Kernel9dfa20931a46931d1e97d1f0efddcf2692afb7a7/Router1dae1948f372e0f1739896655bb7db97d6b08460, RFC6973Jul2013 Informational and arxiv2107.07002v1 abstract only, citation/no-adoption bounds verified. Future return requires named public problem, demonstrated improvement over public/reproducible/local alternatives, necessary fields, explicit producer-consumer/lifecycle, voluntary scoped consent where private, source/user rights/negative conformance and separate owner approval before separately selected implementation. No collection issue registered/selected. Full canonical queue refresh resumes normal loop selection with independent actual gates.

kilo added 1 commit

2026-10-06 08:52:37 +00:00

Assess optional outcome sharing with owner decision reserved 41600d01f9

kilo referenced this pull request

2026-10-06 08:53:29 +00:00

Decide privacy-safe opt-in operational evidence sharing with MI #17

adrian.tkacz added 1 commit

2026-10-06 14:35:47 +00:00

Record owner rejection of current operational intake d54ef5d64c

kilo changed title from ~~Assess optional operational evidence sharing with owner decision reserved~~ to Record rejection of current operational intake and preserve reconsideration

2026-10-06 14:37:19 +00:00

kilo merged commit 98b270e387 into develop

2026-10-06 14:46:00 +00:00

kilo referenced this pull request

2026-10-06 14:47:34 +00:00

Decide privacy-safe opt-in operational evidence sharing with MI #17