Consume pinned MI publications with immutable decision provenance #221
No reviewers
Labels
No labels
accessibility
bug
documentation
duplicate
enhancement
good first issue
help wanted
invalid
P1
P2
P3
question
wontfix
No milestone
No project
No assignees
2 participants
Notifications
Due date
No due date set.
Dependencies
No dependencies set.
Reference
Creatidy/scarcity-router!221
Loading…
Add table
Add a link
Reference in a new issue
No description provided.
Delete branch "issue-176-mi-consumer"
Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?
Refs #176. MERGED into develop as4162f6fa9f774beaf6e92d86b7ebc92f306da4bd after independently accepted owner-authorized inactive/explicit-input implementation. Approved HEADfdc85f17049d7b25d1f8a85f7ea98829a6595916, base287fd5781f6713a4d5fbb273a9c24305fc58e50a; exact merge parents, ancestry and identical reviewed/integrated tree verified. Issue176 closed for this implementation scope only.
Final validation:16 deterministic producer-to-real-selector conformance tests, including post-merge equivalent-tree rerun; make check3048 tests OK/18 skips and basedpyright0 errors/warnings; explicit uv run basedpyright clean; uv sync --only-dev and sanitized offline canonical-cache sync; full wheel/sdist/isolated installed CLI/defaults/MCP/loopback REST package-check; diff/staged whitespace clean.
Whole-PR reviews1/2 REQUEST_CHANGES retained and remediated. Fresh visible native review3 APPROVE/findings[]/limitations[] at exact approved refs, UX no material regression. Ordinals/provenance/results and remediation details remain in comments18940-18951;3/10 consumed, no reset. Reviewer-run tests were denied, not fabricated; primary full gate passed. No hidden launcher, owner result relay or Daybreak.
D082 records one conservative active-admission proposal explicitly NOT accepted or activated. MI19 installed integration and Kernel55 utilized-reference adoption remain downstream acceptance, never prerequisites for this delivered component. No MI/Kernel/GitHub mutation or canonical-reference migration; no main/release/deploy.
Reserve whole-PR ordinary review1/10 for issue176/PR221; default maximum10, no exception/reset. Frozen HEAD59e4434d36fb265f5e68f32cd663f377204b80fc / base=merge-base287fd5781f6713a4d5fbb273a9c24305fc58e50a, canonical open PR targetdevelop matches local objects; clean checkout with one issue-only commit/no merge commit. Source stays frozen through review. Scope: complete730-line issue diff, untrusted versioned public input, independent expected digest/scope/source/history and exact applicability, pre-evaluation freeze/actual explanation utilization, unchanged bootstrap/private policy, immutable local retention/envelope, optional dependency/package compatibility and UX. Read only source/test access, no credentials or implementation conversational context. Native fresh user-visible pr-reviewer session will inherit current model/variant; no hidden invocation or separate worktree. Required validation passed as recorded in PR; actual complete make check process exited with3046 tests OK/18 skips and type0/0, explicit managed basedpyright clean, package-check pass, staged whitespace clean. Remaining installed/live/activation gates are not claimed complete.
Review1 dispatched natively: Agent Manager request am-1792974425793-khj2gm created fresh visible local session ses_e8a65710effeYZNKO8kiVv8FRo, distinct from orchestrator ses_e8a9b19caffe01mc8BFGASyZoS, using existing pr-reviewer role and inherited current model/variant (no override/substitution). Existing same checkout frozen at59e4434/base287fd578; concise acceptance/source-only prompt, read-only exact MI evidence clone, no implementation conversation. Backend identity not inferred from dispatch/UI. Await native terminal result; no approval claimed.
Recovery record: credential-free canonical Git download failed; an unjustified read-only mirror dependency substitution was removed on owner correction. Five new dependency refs were restored to canonical Forgejo; there were NO documentation-link replacements and NO external repository writes. Existing authenticated canonical Git transport then succeeded; sanitized offline canonical-cache sync also passed. No further GitHub calls. Packaging check initially caught exact metadata whitespace; corrected only its expected string, then full artifact/install smoke passed. These are diagnosed completed engineering corrections, not findings or owner handoff gates.
Review1/10 terminal outcome REQUEST_CHANGES at frozen59e4434/base287fd578; native final retrieved from exact session ses_e8a65710effeYZNKO8kiVv8FRo after idle. One concrete P2: MI producer active_notices filters effective time but not report-observation provenance; inadmissible retraction (future acquisition/publication/observation, stale/unknown freshness) could restore a withdrawn positive annotation. Required remediation: consumer restoration-admissibility guard retaining conservative withdrawals/history plus real decision-path tests. No approval; source freeze now released for scoped remediation. Reviewer inspected entire actual10-path diff and installed exact canonical dependency modules, repeated object/currentness checks; optional external-clone access and reviewer test command were denied, so no reviewer-run tests were claimed. Native session had a separate source-only conversation; no implementation context, credential or platform writes. One consumed ordinal,9 remain; next whole-PR review must be fresh. No desired verdict or reset.
Remediation
f72cb3219dfixes review1 P2: only public, non-future, explicitly fresh retraction observations can remove predecessor revocations; inadmissible restoration leaves conservative withdrawal intact without modifying retained history. Actual decision/envelope tests cover future retrieval/observation/publication, stale/unknown freshness/rights, valid restoration, pending effective time and retained immutable notice bytes. Post-fix15 consumer tests pass; full make check3047 tests OK/18 skips and final basedpyright0 errors/warnings (tracked process exited); explicit managed type check clean; package-check full build/artifact/isolated-installed surfaces pass; uv sync --only-dev offline canonical cache and diff/staged whitespace pass.Reserve fresh whole-PR review2/10 at HEADf72cb3219dc51824bae56db02ea5893ddee5f0a6 over unchanged base=merge-base287fd5781f6713a4d5fbb273a9c24305fc58e50a. Review1 REQUEST_CHANGES remains consumed,8 invocations remain after this dispatch. Existing clean same checkout frozen for complete PR review, not narrow fix-only verification; no backend-identity inference or desired verdict. Remaining activation/installed acceptance untouched.
Review2 native provenance: Agent Manager request am-1792975453403-l09tsl created fresh visible local session ses_e8a55c2e8ffexDFko8f6TetjYa with existing read-only pr-reviewer role, inherited selected model/variant/no override. Distinct conversation, source-only acceptance and complete frozen f72cb321/base287fd578 instructions; installed exact canonical dependency source available within permitted checkout. No implementation conversation, desired verdict, runtime-backend inference, source mutations or separate worktree. Await actual terminal result.
Review2/10 actual terminal REQUEST_CHANGES atf72cb321/base287fd578, exact native session ses_e8a55c2e8ffexDFko8f6TetjYa result retrieved after idle; limitations[]. Complete whole-PR inspection plus installed exact dependency provenance verified; reviewer test execution denied, no test PASS invented. One P2 explanation-contract defect: future-only effective claims were omitted by producer effective_at and consequently labeled unknown, while unsupported semantics/unknown values were conflated. Positive admission remained conservative. Remediate using retained exact-binding evidence for negative dispositions alongside producer effective projection; retain current valid facts until future successor's boundary, separate absent/unknown from unsupported, add actual selector tests. Freeze released for scoped fix;2 consumed,8 remaining, no approval/reset.
Remediation
fdc85f1704: exact-binding retained future-only claims now explain FUTURE without supplying their value; producer effective projection still governs current versions, and a future successor does not displace a current valid fact. Unknown amounts/unit/assertion/basis and absent knowledge are distinct from unsupported native meanings/units/unrepresentable values. Added deterministic actual-decision tests for all requested cases.16 consumer tests pass. Complete sanitized make check exited with3048 tests OK/18 skips and final type0 errors/0 warnings; explicit managed basedpyright0/0; package-check rebuilt artifacts and installed defaults/CLI/MCP/REST pass; canonical offline uv sync, diff/staged whitespace pass. Full validation process bgp_175af5aa4001HL4n0N3MHESyOD exited, no duplicate run or unobserved pass.Reserve whole-PR review3/10 at frozen HEADfdc85f17049d7b25d1f8a85f7ea98829a6595916, base=merge-base287fd5781f6713a4d5fbb273a9c24305fc58e50a; complete PR, clean same checkout. Reviews1/2 REQUEST_CHANGES remain consumed;7 slots remain after dispatch. No desired verdict, code/authority expansion, default activation or downstream acceptance claim. Scope and threat model unchanged.
Review3/10 terminal APPROVE, findings[], limitations[] at exact HEADfdc85f17049d7b25d1f8a85f7ea98829a6595916 / base=merge-base287fd5781f6713a4d5fbb273a9c24305fc58e50a. Native Agent Manager request am-1792976616947-j5jek7 -> fresh visible session ses_e8a4401d7ffePPBRASFo3AFcGb; terminal JSON retrieved from that exact idle session. Native tool trace shows independent complete10-path/834-addition diff and actual pinned package source/provenance, canonical getters, source/security/temporal/retention/package/UX checks and repeated clean/ref checks. No material UX regression; installed/live acceptance not claimed. Reviewer-run unittest denied before execution, no invented test PASS; primary complete gates passed. Conversation/source scope and distinct execution session verified; inherited selected model/variant, backend identity not inferred from model self-report/UI. Reviews1/2 REQUEST_CHANGES preserved;3 consumed, no further review needed unless refs change.
Immediate pre-merge issue176 re-fetch has no exclusion labels and unchanged owner-directed acceptance. Canonical PR open/unmerged/mergeable targetdevelop; exact HEAD/base match local and fetched origin refs, clean worktree, three issue-only commits/no feature merge commits. Full post-fix3048-test gate/18 skips and type0/0 plus package-check/whitespace passed. All authorized implementation criteria satisfied; no default/live admission, calibration or downstream receipt acceptance claimed. READY_TO_MERGE under the existing explicit owner /loop authority; proceed via supported Forgejo merge stylemerge, no force/auto/delete.