Router inference-only authority boundary with preserved legacy editing (#180) #198
No reviewers
Labels
No labels
accessibility
bug
documentation
duplicate
enhancement
good first issue
help wanted
invalid
P1
P2
P3
question
wontfix
No milestone
No project
No assignees
2 participants
Notifications
Due date
No due date set.
Dependencies
No dependencies set.
Reference
Creatidy/scarcity-router!198
Loading…
Add table
Add a link
Reference in a new issue
No description provided.
Delete branch "issue-180-native-authority-boundary"
Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?
Refs #180.
Integrated Scope
Bounded Router-side phase of the owner-approved staged native-agent migration. Strict administrator-issued
inference_onlygrants permit current server-direct HTTP transport only; native worker routes remain unsupported for those grants. Client tools return to the harness; pins/metadata do not expand authority. Current registration, administrator/client/active-identity and adapter facts are rechecked before dispatch. Native continuations retain their original adapter/handle, pin and compare resource-binding identity, refuse changed or unknown replacement bindings, and preserve unchanged turns across benign configuration rebuilds.Legacy omitted/false grants and D-063 project/edit/source/service/authentication behavior are preserved. Device/inode checks are not inode-generation or atomic filesystem fencing, Kernel isolation or external-editor leases. D-073 records scoped authority/negative/source evidence; D-074 and workflow guards require Daybreak through direct Codex after ordinary review/validation at stable exact base/HEAD before completion/merge. No Kilo availability gate, fallback reviewer or cross-repository propagation.
Exact Objects And Integration
Reviewed base/merge-base:
1dae1948f372e0f1739896655bb7db97d6b08460.Reviewed HEAD:
cbfb552a9be55bc9d154a6ce81fa14e84078d176.Merged into develop:
8a0ae13d4b4de96abc1d127c855803ee5e5af5a1, exactly those two parents.Reviewed/integrated source tree:
82297a5ccc2d3bce57bc0e2f1d46acc426cfcf39.Three normal commits preserved:
f679bad,2af3390,cbfb552; 26 scoped files. Canonical supported MCP merge, no force/auto-merge, branch deletion, history rewrite, main/release/deployment or external mutation.Validation And Review
Sanitized locked sync PASS; full hard-bounded foreground make check: 2738 tests PASS, 17 skips, 611.433s. Both basedpyright checks zero diagnostics; full/staged whitespace PASS. Recorded tested patch exactly verified against unchanged committed source. Integrated develop acceptance: 45 continuation/binding/composed fake-Codex/legacy-ZCode tests PASS, 30.920s; clean exact local/fetched develop verified.
Current complete whole-PR reviews: ordinary ordinal 4 APPROVE/empty findings; independent
gpt-daybreak-blue-latestsecurity ordinal 5 APPROVE/empty findings through direct official Codex at the same exact base/HEAD. Explicit model dispatch, fresh ephemeral/read-only context, bounded execution, no self-report physical identity inference or substitute. Five total ordinals preserved, including earlier-head REQUEST_CHANGES and invalidated approvals. See review receipt comment15519 and issue receipt comment15524.The originally long-reported running gate was an already-completed unconsumed result, not a hung test. Actual process/child absence, terminal success and unchanged source were verified; subsequent security remediation received a new full foreground hard-bounded gate, with completion consumed immediately.
Remaining Issue Gates
This PR is merged, but #180 remains open per its owner disposition: Router-phase evidence alone cannot establish full migration closure, equivalent accepted Kernel replacement or legacy retirement. Current Kernel #50 verification/test-only profile, #52 consumer obligations and #60 installed/composed acceptance do not supply those receipts. No live native/provider/physical/helper/billing/confinement/retirement claim is made. The D-063 path remains intact, and no speculative follow-up or unauthorized external implementation was created.
Exact current review/validation gates passed for base
1dae1948f372e0f1739896655bb7db97d6b08460and HEADcbfb552a9be55bc9d154a6ce81fa14e84078d176.Ordinary independent whole-PR review ordinal 4: APPROVE, empty findings; complete 26-file/three-commit inspection, 173 original pure tests independently rerun, zero type diagnostics and canonical currentness verified.
Required independent security review ordinal 5:
gpt-daybreak-blue-latest, executed directly through official Codex with explicit model flag, fresh ephemeral context and read-only sandbox, 900-second hard bound. APPROVE, empty findings; exact Git base/HEAD, complete security/authority/compatibility/UX context and validation provenance inspected. Model dispatch is verified by the actual CLI invocation; physical runtime identity is not inferred from reviewer self-report. No Kilo model discovery/dispatch or fallback reviewer.Final normal gate: 2738 tests PASS, 17 skips, 611.433s; locked sanitized sync, both basedpyright invocations and whitespace checks PASS. Tested patch exactly matches this unchanged clean HEAD. Five total whole-PR ordinals retained, including earlier-head REQUEST_CHANGES and invalidated approvals; no reset or rewritten history.
This approves the explicitly authorized bounded Router-side phase and Router-specific workflow correction. It does not establish Kernel replacement/installed acceptance or legacy retirement. Fresh issue #180 and linked Kernel #50/#52/#60 evidence preserve those separate gates; #180 must remain open rather than be closed solely on this Router-phase receipt.